gideon blackblade returning from exile with incorrect loyalty.
During my turn, I exiled Gideon Blackblade at  loyalty under Banishing Light. Opponent proceeded to remove the Banishing Light on his following turn and Gideon returned with  loyalty instead of his original .
There were no effects in play that would increase the number of counters added to a pw (and even if Vorinclex was in play he would enter at  loyalty).
I've included the log of the interaction and checked it at event 
Edit: I've tried to include the log but the bug submission was failing (log too big?) so I removed it... I'll try adding it via e-mail submission.
Edit2: Had the same block of text twice in my post.
I can't seem to be able to submit my log (probably too big?) so I'm sending an excerpt of it that hopefully is enough. I'll try to reproduce the bug tomorrow with a friend and screen record it if needed be.