Ecological Appreciation potential bug - I was playing in a Strixhaven Sealed event, and tried to cast Ecological Appreciation for X = 4. I selected the 4 cards, and waited for my opponent to make their choice, but when the card resolved, nothing was added to the board. I had no creatures, my opponent had an elemental token, and Efreet Flamepainter, and maybe one other creature, but nothing with text that should have prevented Ecological Appreciation from working.
Same thing just happened to me in the Block Constructed event probably losing me the game. X=3, no cards entered the battlefield.
Ecological Appreciation is bugged on MTG Arena. I entered a Strixhaven draft and played it for x = 4. The spell did NOTHING. This is extremely frustrating and I would like a draft credit.
Cast Ecological Appreciation for X=6, chose 4 valid targets from my library, and when the spell resolved, all 4 options were shuffled back into my library. To early in the game to determine if I would have won (since both me and my opponent were still up 20 life) but it was likely had this resolved! The first time I encountered this card it also bugged out. My opponent cast it and it only showed me 2 of the 4 cards selected to shuffle back into the library. The other two were unlisted and went onto the battle field.
Common Wizards, I paid money to do a draft and expect to be able to do the draft and win if I can. This cost me gems and time. I want the cost of the draft refunded.
The same issue here with X=4 and all cards chosen from the library.
That possibly cost me a game and a draft.
Playing Strixhaven quick draft I casted ECOLOGICAL APPRECIATION with X=3, then searched 4 creatures with different names and nothing was put onto the battlefield. I lost the game and the draft.
In a Premier Draft (log attached), my opponent cast Ecological Appreciation, made selection for targets, upon which the game client showed me only two creature options to select for my choices to me shuffled back in to their library. Ecological Appreciation allows UP TO 4 targets to be made by the caster of the spell, so the client showing only two targets is a valid and expected behavior. The issue is that upon selecting both available targets, two other un-shown creatures were returned to the battlefield. These were not shown as targets, not shown as options to me to select, and otherwise could not be identified. Please explain why the appropriate options were not shown during the resolution of the spell, which was at worst case my opponent exploited a bug in the interface, and at best case the interface actively misrepresenting the spell effects and options being selected.
Same happened to me. PC, Strixhaven Quickdraft, X=4, all 4 from library, during choosing the last time out of my opponent ran out, maybe that was the reason for ending the cards effect. Still something different should happen than giving no cards to the owner of Ecological Appreciation who played in time.
During Premier draft I casted ecological appreciation for x = 4 paying therefore 7 mana total, i've selected 4 differents creatures with cmc 4 and 3 annnnndd nothing happened. No cards influencing the "from the labriary" casts on the board and still.
I lost my Strixhaven quick draft because of this. Game was close. Four cards selected. Nothing happened.
Loosing real money because of a persistend bug is a clear refund.
I lost a Strixhaven quick draft game because of this bug. Cast for X=4, chose 4 creatures with CMC of 3 or 4, then card went into exile without putting anything on board. With no board, I quickly lost after that.
Oddly, the second time I tried it in quick draft with X=3, I chose 4 creatures with CMC of 3, and got two cards on the battlefield as expected, then the card went into exile.
Played this card in Premiere Draft. Paid X=4, picked 2 creatures from library and 2 creatures from graveyard, only one card appeared on the battlefield.
Same issue. Playing on PC in a Sealed event. Picked 4 creatures from my library. Nothing resolved. Here is my log from right after the issue.
Why does this persist ??? You throw too many perfectly reasonable cards out of the game then you keep the indestructible pig and you never repair your programming failures ...sell the **** company to someone who understands the game Hasbro and stop wasting our time and resources.
Also had the same issue. Playing on PC in Premiere Draft event.
Had the same issue, with X=5. I Had searched from library all of them. There were no problem when I searched from library and graveyard.
My opponent cast Ecological Appreciation against me, and the interface only showing two targets that were selected. As the card can select up to 4 targets, two is a legal number to select when casting the spell, so all targeted cards are expected to be shown to the opponent to select what is shuffled back in to their library. After selecting both targets shown to me to be shuffled back in, the spell then placed two other creatures on to the battlefield that were not shown as options. This is highly misleading and incorrect card behavior to not show all targets to the opponent to make selections. Please advise.
Upon resolution of Ecological Appreciation (X=7, Vorinclex, Windreader Sphinx, Kogla, Elder Gargaroth), no creatures appear on the battlefield and it’s as if I hadn’t even casted Ecological Appreciation, leaving me with tapped lands and an empty duodenum. FIX!
Michael Shawn#79266 commented
Same here. Not working
I ran into the same bug as well when x = 2 and lost the game due to it.
This is crazy.
I am losing rank games because of an bug when i use ecological appreciation, i select 4 cards, and the all 4 Get shuffeled back into the libary:( extremly frustrating, to lose ranks so close to ending event because of this error, never been so close to Diamond before this....