Algorithm Improvement
I'm sure you're getting a lot of complaints about how one-sided your algorithm is not being impartial and often times screwing over players with land draws that should not be happening in a purely random sample - so my complaint can be added to that pile.
But, an idea for changing the algorithm to improve randomization would be having the program assign a number to each card remaining in a deck and pile shuffling the cards into X amount of piles (let's say 6). It can repeat this process Y amount of times then take the middle of the pile and put those cards on top. A better template would be from the card shuffler for poker sets from stores.
-
Screenshot_20240610-124913.png 1955 KB -
Screenshot_20240610-124925.png 2544 KB -
Screenshot_20240607-112339_Gallery.jpg 431 KB -
Screenshot_20240527-142312.png 1854 KB -
Screenshot_20240527-142521.png 1852 KB -
WHAT THE HELL.jpg 119 KB -
cant-be.jpg 223 KB -
Screen 2.JPG 286 KB -
Screen 1.JPG 181 KB -
BS Lands.png 3906 KB -
IMG_0138.png 7889 KB -
Log20240324_222223.log 10925 KB -
Screenshot (6).png 3846 KB -
Screenshot (5).png 3553 KB -
Screenshot (4).png 3460 KB -
Log20240215_120905.log 43967 KB -
Log20240215_120905.log 43967 KB -
Screenshot_20240131_122750_Magic.jpg 1228 KB -
Screenshot_2024-01-09-11-27-21-65_0d1fccac8b78e37cdc1dccf8a6bd9734.jpg 1426 KB -
Capture.PNG 96 KB -
MTGA 1_8_2024 2_50_36 AM.png 6234 KB -
MTGA 1_8_2024 2_37_18 AM.png 8795 KB -
Log20240108_023749.log 237 KB -
Log20231216_111218.log 39774 KB -
Log20231119_150216.log 135 KB -
image_2023-11-09_153846124.png 1726 KB -
shit shuffler and resource destruction.png 2073 KB -
UTC_Log - 10-29-2023 07.01.59.log 9462 KB -
draw after that.png 861 KB -
this is why your game sucks.png 850 KB -
Log20231019_190627.log 32 KB -
image_2023-10-17_193618112.png 2312 KB -
Screenshot_20231016-073005.png 2222 KB -
Screenshot_20231016-073057.png 2131 KB -
Screenshot_20231016-073041.png 2090 KB -
Screenshot_20231016-073203.png 1081 KB -
Screenshot_20231010-222137.png 2191 KB -
IMG_3827.png 6205 KB -
IMG_3830.jpeg 438 KB -
IMG_3829.jpeg 471 KB -
IMG_3828.jpeg 434 KB -
whats wrong with this picture wizards.png 1205 KB -
turn 7.png 1157 KB -
Log20230921_181919.log 79 KB -
Screenshot 2023-09-21 at 6.18.39 PM.png 8922 KB -
20230910_120436.jpg 0 KB -
20230830_223020.jpg 0 KB -
20230830_221449.jpg 0 KB -
20230830_221305.jpg 0 KB -
20230830_220515.jpg 0 KB -
20230830_145340.jpg 0 KB -
20230829_143404.jpg 0 KB -
20230829_143305[1].jpg 5198 KB -
image_2023-09-07_212539628.png 1416 KB -
MTGA2.PNG 2873 KB -
MTGA.PNG 4591 KB -
bullshit algorithm.png 1302 KB -
Second mull.png 1342 KB -
3rd mull.png 1184 KB -
5th game like this and i have optimal lands.png 1040 KB -
draw.PNG 134 KB -
fix your fucking game.png 2781 KB -
fix your game already.png 1391 KB -
IMG_2120.png 8684 KB -
bullshit mulligan rules.png 900 KB -
tell me your algo sucks.png 854 KB -
1692045296548-1.JPEG 170 KB -
Screenshot_20230812_094952_Magic.jpg 1210 KB -
Screenshot_20230810_222931_Magic.jpg 1281 KB -
and this.png 1428 KB -
cancer.png 989 KB -
explain this.png 1153 KB -
explain this wizardtards.png 882 KB -
bullshit.png 1898 KB -
Cancer2.png 1860 KB -
cancer.png 1419 KB -
IMG_0633.png 8749 KB -
IMG_0632.png 7489 KB -
IMG_0631.png 7524 KB -
fix your dumb game.png 2469 KB -
fix your shuffler.png 528 KB -
Log20230715_082937.log 11211 KB -
3BA76B44-6F49-456A-9E8E-6A156825FA58.png 8450 KB -
18DF26FC-C31C-4D94-8DC7-D0E71F598D59.png 8060 KB -
5F434AB9-5892-4A05-AF8E-6D514EC3EBBA.png 8084 KB -
Log20230625_154123.log 55 KB -
IMG_0150.png 5061 KB -
IMG_0148.png 4829 KB -
IMG_0149.png 1869 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl6.jpg 668 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl5.jpg 598 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl4.jpg 552 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl3.jpg 596 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl2.jpg 565 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl1.jpg 654 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl9.jpg 557 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl8.jpg 605 KB -
Matchmaking not working in Brawl7.jpg 527 KB -
21機会で土地2枚(土地割合28/80).png 1712 KB -
Log20230415_203925.log 390 KB -
UTC_Log - 04-09-2023 20.42.33.log 40817 KB -
2.jpg 1418 KB -
3.jpg 1355 KB -
5.jpg 1511 KB -
4.jpg 1316 KB -
1.jpg 1302 KB -
Log20230405_151758.log 24104 KB -
2.jpg 1418 KB -
4.jpg 1316 KB -
3.jpg 1355 KB -
5.jpg 1511 KB -
1.jpg 1302 KB -
Log20230320_064436.log 25029 KB -
D772DA3B-B7C2-44A6-92F3-3A9B8E0E622C.png 7090 KB -
Log20230312_111055.log 53 KB -
C5639E2A-87DF-43E0-BF68-86266D422C16.png 7776 KB -
Log20230308_145416.log 224 KB -
Log20230308_145206.log 223 KB -
Log20230308_145125.log 223 KB -
Log20230308_145041.log 223 KB -
Log20230308_150641.log 269 KB -
Log20230306_204335.log 93 KB -
Log20230306_204335.log 93 KB -
Log20230218_082637.log 11114 KB -
error arena.jpg 631 KB -
Log20230214_210324.log 128 KB -
Log20230213_182535.log 125 KB -
IMG_0027.jpg 1013 KB -
IMG_0029.jpg 925 KB -
IMG_0016.jpg 885 KB -
Screenshot 2023-01-30 at 1.38.42 PM.png 3546 KB -
Log20230115_233637.log 118 KB -
Log20221230_163502.log 22 KB -
Schermata 2022-12-18 alle 11.54.36.png 9894 KB -
Log20221218_115607.log 264 KB -
Log20221218_115553.log 264 KB -
Log20221217_143052.log 43 KB -
log.log 20235 KB -
Screen Shot 2022-12-09 at 20.49.05.png 6034 KB -
Screen Shot 2022-12-09 at 20.27.43.png 6282 KB -
Hasbro-Executive.png 484 KB -
Log20221129_115210.log 11511 KB -
Screenshot (61).png 2616 KB -
Log20221116_150821.log 222 KB -
Log20221012_103812.log 37 KB -
Log20221013_162401.log 8 KB -
Log20221011_185937.log 23145 KB -
Log20221005_201039.log 6005 KB -
Screenshot 2022-09-20 010530.jpg 11 KB -
Log20220904_144214.log 2490 KB -
Log20220823_113059.log 38 KB -
Log20220805_202829.log 21 KB -
bullshit.png 3229 KB -
bullshit2.0.jpg 41 KB -
Screenshot_2022-07-18-07-34-18-91_0d1fccac8b78e37cdc1dccf8a6bd9734.jpg 1427 KB -
Screenshot_2022-07-18-07-31-07-65_0d1fccac8b78e37cdc1dccf8a6bd9734.jpg 1379 KB -
Screenshot_2022-07-18-07-54-40-52_0d1fccac8b78e37cdc1dccf8a6bd9734.jpg 1379 KB -
Screenshot (3).png 4304 KB -
Screenshot (4).png 4193 KB -
Screenshot (2).png 5061 KB -
MTGA 27_06_2022 06_51_49 a. m..png 2120 KB -
Screenshot 2022-06-06 234559.png 356 KB -
Untitled drawing (1).png 1140 KB -
Untitled drawing (2).jpg 44 KB -
Log20220527_091110.log 14819 KB -
Log20220525_095310.log 12675 KB -
Thank you Wizards!.jpg 552 KB -
2 lands in 17 cards.jpg 527 KB -
Thank you Wizards!.jpg 552 KB -
2 lands in 17 cards.jpg 527 KB -
shufller is fine 5.jpg 527 KB -
shufller is fine 3, 3 lands in 16 cards.jpg 510 KB -
shufller is fine 2.jpg 473 KB -
shufller is fine 3, 3 lands in 15 cards.jpg 503 KB -
shufller is fine.jpg 440 KB -
shufller is fine 4.jpg 530 KB -
Screenshot_20220505-154301_Magic.jpg 1444 KB -
Screenshot_20220504-144021_Magic.jpg 1551 KB -
Screenshot_20220504-144033_Magic.jpg 1360 KB -
Log20220319_083435.log 62 KB -
Pairing Algorithm 01.png 4582 KB -
Pairing Algorithm 02.png 3411 KB -
Matchmaking.jpg 45 KB -
Log20220106_190437.log 72 KB -
ShareX_2021-11-24-06-07-23-574.png 40 KB -
Log20211002_231206.log 33 KB -
Screenshot_20210930-123116_Magic.jpg 1614 KB -
Log20210928_124854.log 121 KB -
Log20210801_112305.log 70 KB -
2021-04-01 (3).png 2328 KB -
quick_draft_gold.png 1868 KB -
quick_draft_plat.png 1842 KB -
Log20201228_223510.log 621 KB -
Log20201228_221503.log 587 KB -
UTC_Log - 08-14-2020 17.53.18.log 179 KB -
opponent-goes-first-1.png 2729 KB -
Log20200509_141030.log 3962 KB -
Log20200319_195414.log 532 KB

-
Anima#17895 commented
I enjoy playing MTGA but my God it feels rigged some times. I lose a few matchs in a row and then when I change decks its seems to put me up aganst decks that a designed to either nullify and undermine the mechanic I have chosen or happens to play at the speeds that put my deck at a disavantage in termes of play speed. I switch it up again and boom puts me up aganst a deck that is clearly designed to undermine the new deck I have chosen.
-
Bullseye614#68447 commented
I will never pay money to play this game for as long as the matchmaking stays the way it is. Obviously pairing me up against decks that are designed to win against whatever I'm playing is so stupid that I am barely hanging on to free play at the moment and I feel like even then, I shouldn't waste resources in game. I go up against 20 lifegain decks in a row but then I put a few cards in that stop lifegain and never see one. I agree with every other player on these board. STOP RIGGING MATCHES AND USE A RANDOM PAIRINGS GENERATOR. Simple as far as I'm concerned: you dont fix this and I refuse to give you money.
-
rzero#57002 commented
The game is unplayable for me at the moment, because I'm trying to play ranked with 'go wide' creature decks and so the matchmaker decides that 90% of my opponents should maindeck 4 Meathook Massacres. There is no way that this is a true representation of the actual meta game, just check any stat tracking website, it's clearly not true. I should see far more mono-white decks than mono-black. Can you at least explain why you think this is a good idea?
-
jeffgoddin#77109 commented
I've been keeping track, the number of less the 2% chance floods is like 10%, which is statistically highly improbable. Driving me mad. 10 out of 14 when there are 17 in a 40 card deck? Please. Shuffler is NOT fine.
-
Sworfs JugendFeuerwehr#68690 commented
Absolutely can confirm this! I made a flash/rouge Deck (no NETDECK or some other ********, 100% just played by me) and played like 30 games with it ONLY!!!!!!!!!! getting Mono Green or White as opponents. Every time! In the freeplayqueue!
This is so bad and ruins absolutely any diversity and fun you could maybe have, but the matchmaking makes the game as a whole kind of unplayable. Even the fact that the "freeplayqueue" is literally the same as the ranked queue just for loosers who dont want to "compete".
My suggestion: Give us a individually Banlist with like 10 Cards beeing able to be banned in freeplay for like 1 Week - you will not face them. So it would be actually able to build some Decks that are not forced by your (really bad) matchmaking system to play the same (Netdecked) 5 standartised, repetitive Decks over and over again
-
mdazy#86953 commented
The matchmaking in standard ranked and in normal play is literally trash!!!
Recently it became very difficult to proceed in career...it looks like the opponents are chosen based on the deck I want to play.
Where is the randomness (aka fairness)?? Please hire some statisticians for task/piece of code which requires statistical way of thinking. -
Sol#42915 commented
I'd like to add to this:
You guys have NO problem managing deck strength matchmaking in limited play (often favoring same color pairs, it seems - and this is having watched A LOT of MTGA limited play)
Why is it so tough to AT LEAST match the gimme decks against other free decks???
I've changed NOT A SINGLE CARD, and yet I'm matched in "PLAY" mode against actual constructed decks often. It's absolutely ridiculous.
I can easily go look up a list of current meta decks, so I expect you can too. Why not cross-reference these decks and match them against each other in play mode? I could find better matchups playing in bronze ranked play than I can in what should be a casual mode.
And sure, you're always going to have people who are selfish and just want their quick daily wins bringing T1 decks into a casual setting. But you could shut that down in a hurry if you matched them against each other, and clearly there is an existing deck strength matchmaking system in the code.
I've said it over and over but if you don't create a casual arena for Magic fans, you're going to lose out on a LOT of new players and older casual players alike (and, more importantly, clearly, on the MONEY they would be spending).
Plus, it's extremely frustrating. And why, you ask, don't I just make T1 decks and do the same thing? Because I don't want to be that Ahole. And why not play ranked then? I don't always want to play that sort of Magic. Any time, I could take a good deck into bronze ranked play (or silver, or gold, ranked doesn't really get competitive until plat or maybe diamond rank) and win 80+% of games but that's not always FUN.
-
Great Bear#30124 commented
This is gross. It also seems illegal since if one can win crystals (ie have monetary value), by not disclosing that the algorithms are not random, people are misled about their chances of winning.
-
Jace#11366 commented
I am 100% about this and was about to post my own. I spent over 4 hours today just trying to get daily wins due to bad algorithms and bad luck. I want to feel I can play because I want to; because it is fun. This is NOT fun. Paper is fun. This is torture. It is all win-oriented at the cost of fun. If you play for fun you will lose over and over which makes no progress towards daily allotments. Even when I play meta decks, it isn't fun as algorithms make bad match ups, mirror matches which get boring, etc. At least if the losses counted as half a win or something, it would make it more reasonable to play for fun and not care so much about winning all the time.
-
Lil Roguey#19500 commented
also drawing half the lands in a deck does not help either xD
-
Lil Roguey#19500 commented
Matchmaking is super broken. I win 3 times and suddenly i play 12 times against the same decks(minion of the mighty) and keep losing on turn 3 which is ridiculous. This has to be fixed. matchmaking should be random and not made to force losses so we should buy packs. if this keeps up people will just leave the game...
-
pasemaker#16327 commented
1. Please merge this idea with the number of other "matchmaking" product suggestions. It's bigger than it appears here.
2. Save me from this white/green life gain meta deck ****.
-
Patrice#33508 commented
I agree- at least admit that it isn't 50:50
-
bluelovers#54683 commented
idea is
1. do distribute before shuffle
- distribute lands
- distribute cards and insert lands every 4 cards
https://github.com/bluelovers/ws-mtg/blob/9518363fca3c0be1e3e05258919878f6fbf08453/packages/mtg-deck-shuffle/dist/index.cjs.development.js#L93
2. split to 12 chunk and random merge it
https://github.com/bluelovers/ws-mtg/blob/9518363fca3c0be1e3e05258919878f6fbf08453/packages/mtg-deck-shuffle/dist/index.cjs.development.js#L21----
optional hack
at begin the match
ask player choose he want at latest has 2 land or not?if all player choose yes
then will make sure player has 2 land in start
if not all player allow this then random chose yes or notthen draw 7 card, if land < 2, random swap a card into library and pick random land out
if handsize is 6 , then only make sure has 1 land -
KAun4#10926 commented
Wotc just didn't care and they keep The "smoothing"on for purpose
The insolence of this company has reach yet new height and they deleted old thread about this issue.
Here is screenshot from the old thread. They started to get afraid that is why the thread was deleted.If any of you want your money back file a complain with your consumer protection agency, don't wait. They cite the policy and the policy states they can take your money and you have no rights after that.
"WOTC is located in the US State of Washington. You can file a consumer protection complaint online with the Washington State Attorney General’s office at https://fortress.wa.gov/atg/formhandler/ago/ComplaintForm.aspx. Basically complain that due to a defect in their product, you aren’t getting what you paid for, nor are you getting appropriately compensated, and you feel that is a violation of consumer protection laws."
Also consider to give 1-star rating to the MTGA-app on mobile if you feel disappointed to this game.
I got mine back when I brought this issue up and made order issue ticket and I am sure Wotc has to give it to other players also back because the thing they have cooking isn’t technically okay.
https://mtgarena-support.wizards.com/hc/en-us/requests/newIf unsatisfied customers don't have time or don't know how to phrase yourself here is the form I used:
I want full refund of my spent money of the purchase -- invoice: --. I have the full amount of gems to refund on my account and you can just delete the sleeves and avatar off my account.
I made the purchase in belief that I would gain gems to play digital equivalent of the original paper Magic the Gathering. After some gaming I realized that this is not the case and the MTGA is far cry from the paper MTG. MTGA uses Hand Smoothing and opponent deciding algorithms at a level I consider egregious, which derives the game to be completely different than the original paper Magic the Gathering. Smoothing causes some players to build their BO1 decks in a fashion that exploits it.
This has not been made clear to the players who makes the purchases which can be seen as intentionally action. It is never mentioned within the game!
When you are not fixing the problem and not clearly and openly speaking about it, shows clear intent and is borderline fraud. If the refund request is not responded during week -- I am forced to contact this issue to the PayPal buyer protection, and after that to Competition and Consumer Authority if there is no sign of your side of co-operation.
-
Nightchills#50250 commented
The real question is why are you wasting your time with a game repeatedly that cheats you. Arena is developed to take a **** on you the second to start winning to much. As you already noticed. And yes you will only see certain types of deck depending on what your playing. Its not a fair system. Hasbro is the worst thing to EVER happen to MTG and MTGA. You want things to change stop being a ***** AND TAKE A STAND STOP PLAYING. If the player base dies maybe they will wake up. That's is the only real power you have as a consumer. Take you business else where.
-
MysticSquid#48745 commented
your hand smoothing algorithim changes the math in a deck. It may help new players but it changes the way an experienced players deck works, ptutting them at a disadvantage, which is a direct violation of your terms of service. I have been tracking your shuffler since before hand smoothing, I build a deck in paper and copy it in arena to test your shuffler. Since hand smoothing has been instituted the results are like night to day. The only real option you guys have is give the option to turn off hand smoothing, If a new player starts playing they have it , but for us experienced players who know how to actually build a deck we can turn it off . It won't put us at a disadvantage like being forced to use it does. your terms of service explicitly sys anything that gives an advantage or puts another player at a disadvantage is strictly prohibited and thus it should effect hand smoothing. I hope you do respond and possibly look at the option to turn off hand smoothing seriously as you violating the TOS yourselves would rend them void. I have been playing magic since beta was released and I really would not want to see it tarnished by something so stupid as lack of actual testing of of your programming before installing.
-
derwhitephantom#75309 commented
Seriously as i just finished this i played against 2 decks where my opponent had 3 of the same cards in their opening hand and the next game had 3 of the same cards in their opening hand lol.
meanwhile i got 4 lands in a row so the clumping is legit and the program is drunk again and needs to go home -
derwhitephantom#75309 commented
I came up with a brilliant new product for Wizards of the Coast here..
And here me out.
Fix MTG Arena and then release it after all the bugs and ****** algorithm has been fixed.
Then you can have a product that actually works and is fun to play instead of this hot garbage. Id might actually spend money on it -
Dameon Geppetto#78715 commented
OH BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE!
More breaking of gameplay that is. The Crimson Vow patch literally broke the shuffler.
Matchmaking is still the most broken part of the game, but now everyone is forced to take mulligans more than 30% of the time.
Less and less matches are fun and challenging. You either stomp to victory or get rolled 80% of the time. Not fun at all. I record and post the results of this travesty of a matchmaking system, but as long as the stans keep shilling out cash to Hasbro for this borderline criminal shell game disguised as an RNG game, nothing will get done.
#boycottHasbro