innkeeper's talent incorrectly doubling +loyalty abilities
Innkeeper's talent is incorrectly doubling the +loyalty planeswalker abilities
This should work the same as doubling season and according to the rules, the doubling effect should increase only the loyalty counters put on the planeswalker when its first entering the battlefield. the loyalty abilities are considered costs and should not be doubled.
Steps:
- Play and level innkeeper's talent to level 3
- play a planeswalker and note that the counters CORRECTLY get doubled when it enters the battle field.
- use a +loyalty ability, and note that the amount of counters that get added are doubled as well, which is incorrect (at least according to the rules i have been searching)
Mekell#57554
shared this idea
-
DAC169#34537
commented
Considering the vast amount of overpowered cards that they don't ban, I'm not surprised at all that they won't ban Innkeeper's Talent.
-
PressureChamber#23947
commented
The true error is that such an overpowered card was printed in the first place and that it hasn't been banned to correct the mistake yet.
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Doubling Season is worded "if an EFFECT would put ..." while Innkeeper's Talent says "if YOU would put ...". The first wording excludes costs, while the second includes them.