Split Up needs to give op a chance to respond
Just lost a game because Arena didn't give me a chance to tap my creatures for mana when op cast Split Up because I had no effects I could play 😖
I had Enduring Vitality in play. I should have won the game next turn. ðŸ˜
I would appreciate some sort of refund. This never would have happened in a paper game.
-
bonsai#70698 commented
Oops. I was wrong and Rezzahan is entirely correct.
Chrysoprace should've been able to tap his creatures to create X floating mana and avoid Split Up's "destroy all untapped creatures" effect even if he had no instant responses as sinks for that floating mana.
See rules 405.6c, 605.3a, and 605.3b.
-
Rezzahan#77802 commented
@bonzai
Irrelevant. A player can tap permanents for mana abilities with instant timing, just like any other unrestricted activated ability. Arena doesn't seem to recognize that, though, and skips ahead. Hence, bug. -
bonsai#70698 commented
Did you have an Instant in response that could be put on the stack?