Rescue from the Underworld bugged with control effects
If you use a control effect (dragonlord silumgar) on an opponent's creature, and then cast Rescue from the Underworld sacrificing that creature, Rescue from the Underworld reads that both will return to play under your control.
It does not. It returns it to play under their control... :(
Platform - PC
Repeatability - simply use those two effects, it will repeat
Log is of a game with this result.

-
CHS_FutureGazer#20608 commented
Same thing occurred for me - mac user.
-
Xeraph#63841 commented
Exact same problem on PC Arena.
Replay, see turns 8 through 11.
https://www.17lands.com/user/game_replay/20241226/1953041bcefc43419c0364022215d7cf/0 -
kugo commented
Exact same thing happened to me, same two cards. Log file attached.
-
Dysent#40734 commented
I keep trying to attach the log and it keeps failing :(