"Quina, Qu Gourmet" and "Sin, Spira's Punishment" interaction
If you play "Sin, Spira's Punishment" while you have Quina on board, you are supposed to get an untapped 1/1 green frog token per token that Sin will make on their enter the battlefield trigger. However, each frog token enters tapped, which is not the correct result.
Expected Result: 1/1 green frog tokens created by Quina is produced untapped
Actual Result: 1/1 green frog tokens is produced TAPPED from Sin's trigger.
stackdamage#71765
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Not a bug. Just your understanding of what should happen is wrong.
Consider if you had Mondrak or Ojer Tag instead. Do you expect those additional tokens to enter untapped? I assume not. Why then do you expect an additional token via some other replacement effect to enter untapped? After all, only the number and type of tokens are changed, any status or other additional effect is applied to ALL toklens created by the effect.