Bugs in "Zidane, Tantalus Thief
A zidane,Tantalus Thief in my field was stolen by a Relms Sketching used by my opponent who copied the zidane,Tantalus Thief. During my opponent's combat phase my stolen zidane,Tantalus Thief was sent to my graveyard and did not return. My opponent used nothing but Relms Sketching.
And I lost.
Please fix it.
さもぬ#54790
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Your opponent created a copy of your Zidane, and then took control of your Zidane with the ETB trigger? Then they controlled two legendary permanents with the same name, and the legend rule made them put one into their owner's graveyard. That was your Zidane, your opponent kept the copy. And your Zidane does not return, because he was dead. The end of the control change effect does not bring it back to the battlefield. If Zidane had lived to the cleanup step, then the creature would have returned to you due to the control change effect ending.