Protection not Working Properly
I had on the board an "Alseid of Life's Bounty" and an "Ajani's Pridemate".
The opponent attacked me and I blocked with "Ajani's Pridemate". Before damage, I used Alseid's ability to give my Pridemate protection from the color of the attacking creature.
Even with protection, my creature suffered damage and died, while Protection is supposed to prevent any damage caused from sources of that color.
No screenshot was taken because I didn't have enough time to do it.
Similar thing happened to me... The opponent used the ( -2 ) from his narset of the ancient way to kill my Lurrus of the Dream-Den, but it was under protection from blue. (sacrificed my Alseid)
( -2 ) Draw a card, than you may discard a card. When you discard a nonland card this way, Narset of the Ancient Way deal damage equal to that card's converted mana cost to target creature or planeswalker.
Well, the card discarted was blue but anyway it should not matter since the source come from the Narset, which is also blue.... protection is not working properly
I blocked a Skynight Vanguard with my Stonecoil Serpent : Skynight did damage and my Serpent died.
Same issue here. My two Shifting Ceratops blocked a hydroid Krasis and a Uro. Both of mine died and I lost a ranked match because I couldn't block his Uro the turn after. There was a Leyline Of The Void on the field but nothing else of note.
The same thing happened to me.
Had similar issue. Blocked Anax with a Cerulean Drake, and Anax killed my Drake... Doesn't seem like this should happen. Please fix!
Same issue. Happened several times actually. Happens only during combat damage apparently. Block a creature, cast protection so you don't loose the blocker, then stare in awe as your creature dies. Extremely annoying, since it can mean a loss in many situations. Please fix it, it's amazing that this has been going on for so long.
Just had a similar issue. I blocked a Uro, Titan with my Aurelia, Exemplar and before damage resolved I cast Gods Willing on Aurelia giving it protection from blue. My Aurelia received damage even though it shouldn't have . Next turn I would have had lethal damage and won if Aurelia would have lived.
Cerrulean Drake protection from red against solo scorch spitter. Drake dies. No other cards in play. Lost ranked match.
I also had this issue, here was my scenario:
Blocked a Red/Green Satyr with a Daxos.
Opponent flashes in The Embercleave, equip targeting the satyr.
I decide to cast Gods Willing on my Daxos choosing Red to save it and also still kill his Satyr.
However, not only did my creature die his didn't.
So annoying, this was a game changer and I should've won that match.
Just had a 'Thassa, Deep Dwelling' with 'shadowspear' run over and kill a protection from Blue 'Shifting Ceratops' ..
Please fix the horrible bugs in the protection system as its making it unplayable at the higher levels when stupid thing like this happen . just makes you want to quit playing altogether ..