Hello,

Retribution of the Ancients reads:

{B}, Remove X +1/+1 counters from among creatures you control: Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn.

Expected behaviour:

X = 0, I should be able to use the ability for {B} only.

Actual behaviour:

I cannot use it for X = 0! There is no stipulation that X cannot be 0 in this case.

Thanks very much!
-- Ronald L

I dealt a damage with walking ballista on a devoted druid with a -1/-1 counter on it and it didn't die

1. When Rielle, the Everwise is in play, using Foil's alternate cast method (discarding an Island and another card) only triggers Rielle to draw you 1 card opposed to 2 like it should.
2. Use alternate cost to cast Foil with Rielle in play.
3. Rielle's trigger draws you 1 card.
4. Rielle's trigger should draw 2 cards.

Hi! This artifact reads:

As Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII enters the battlefield, choose white Citizen, blue Camarid, black Thrull, red Goblin, or green Saproling.

{3}, {T}: Create a 1/1 creature token of the chosen color and type.

Attached is a photo of the "Saproling" token. For some reason it's a Camarid but that type has been taken out and Saproling has been stapled on.

This is not a game-breaking bug, but I just found it a little odd!

Thanks,
-- Ronald L

I ulted ugin in commander and wasnt able to play any permanents with his abiltiy. The game wanted me to pay for them even though ugin says i can just play them for free.

Expiedition skulker would not allow me to block with cleric of chill depth

1. Chainer's Ability is activated.
2. dockside extortionist is being cast from graveyard
3. dockside extortionist is being sacrificed.
4. Actual: dockside extortionist is being cast again.
5. Expected: dockside extortionist should only be allowed to be cast once.

Note: Not entirely sure if dockside extortionist was recast multiple times from one activation or chainer activated multiple times. both should not be possible though.

Playing Standard. Mutated Parcel Beast onto a Breeding Pool that was a creature off of Nissa, Who Shakes the World. Chose Parcel Beast to be above the Breeding Pool. Power/Toughness 2/4 plus 3 +1/+1 counters from Nissa making it a 5/7. MTGO represented it as a 3/3. Believe this to be incorrect.

The land card Rainbow Vale says "Tap to Add one mana of any color. An opponent gains control of Rainbow Vale at the beginning of the next end step." But after it is used the first time the card just disappears and never returns under the chosen opponent's control.

first problem I couldnt enchant his creature with capture sphere then it time out and auto enchanted to my vodalian arcanist. then when he enchanted a cat to make it be blocked and I couldnt block it with any of my creatures...it timed out trying to block it and I didnt have time to block the rest.

Necropotence crashes the game into a replay when the stack of cards are going into hand at the end step.
This happens when there are 30+ Necropotence triggers on the stack.
This happens in Commander games, have not tried the event in other formats.

1. Cast and spell with Cascade
2. The cascade trigger hits a spell without any targets.
3. Click to cast.
4. The text is on two lines.

If you cycle Yidaro, Wandering monster with a Rest in Peace effect on the battlefield, he will properly go into the exile zone immediately, but when the triggered ability resolves, he goes from the exile zone back into the deck. I found that Leyline of the Void still counts his Cycle count, but Rest in Peace does not, when it is put into the deck.

Cast idol of endurance this turn.
paid cost and tapped for ability.
but unable to select creature.

Have Nightmare Shepherd in play, and Atris. Atris dies, Nightmare shepherd creates a token. The first time this happens, the Atris-token does not trigger its ETB effect. Second time it happens in a subsequent turn, same card combo, the ETB does trigger. Potentially has to do with playing Atris on the same turn as the token got created the first time, when it didn't trigger.

chaos warp revealed Barrin again after targeting Barrin, and ephemerate stayed exiled after not being cast. I'm very confused

Pulse of the Tangle is bugged! Steps are:

1a. Control one creature.
1b. Opponent A controls 3 creatures, Opponent B controls 0, Opponent C controls 2.
2. Cast Pulse of the Tangle. "Create a 3/3 green Beast creature token. Then if an opponent controls more creatures than you, return Pulse of the Tangle to its owner’s hand."
3. Beast token is created.
4, actual behaviour: Pulse of the Tangle stays in the graveyard. Sadness on the stack.
5, expected behaviour: Pulse of the Tangle would return to my hand.

Thanks guys!

When Hushbringer or Tocatli Honor Guard is on battlefield and Nyxathid is cast and enters the battlefield the the ability of Hishbringer should cause the first ability of Nyxathid to not activate. Therefore since no opponent is chosen the second ability should also not activate. This should cause Nyxathid to enter as 7/7 and stay 7/7 no matter how many cards the opponent has in hand.