I play with 3 friends normally, but since we all have lives, jobs and children, it increasingly difficult for all 4 of us to be available to play at the same time. We need to add a 5th and possibly 6th person, and because it wouldn't be fair to everyone on the rare occasions that we would all be available to play because Spelltable only allows up to 4, we haven't added anyone else, and the games aren't as good as they could be.

5 players + would allow interesting kitchen table play styles like star, mafia, king with two towers

Definitely agree! We could have 8 people sometimes which makes 2 groups nicely, but when we've got 5 or 6 and want to do one big happy pod, it'd be nice to still be able to use Spelltable instead of moving to a Zoom or something.

My playgroup consists of 5 players

I also would like to have this. At least 5 players, why can't we have more players? It's mostly there, don't need to be a perfect layout

I second this. We have a group of 5 or 6 most times and would love to use spelltable but end up having to use discord :(

We play "kitchen table" magic with 5 to 6 people. This is our biggest Spelltable complaint.