This just happened to me with Make Disappear. It asked me to target the spell I wanted to counter (the only spell on the stack) and asked me [Are you sure?] and when I clicked yes it did nothing and the original spell resolved. This has happened multiple times with different counterspells.
This just happened to me with Make Disappear. It asked me to target the spell I wanted to counter (the only spell on the stack) and asked me [Are you sure?] and when I clicked yes it did nothing and the original spell resolved. This has happened multiple times with different counterspells.