Prentiscool#40585
My feedback
1 result found
-
2,463 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Prentiscool#40585
supported this idea
·
Prentiscool#40585
1 result found
Prentiscool#40585
supported this idea
·
I love the historic format, I only really play historic, and I enjoy playing an eternal format on MTGA. I've spent money on every single expansion, and I enjoy my time with the game.
This change makes me not want to spend any more money into the game, purely because the cards that I want to play with could be changed on a whim. It makes me not want to spend wild cards and not want to make new decks out of the fear that cards in it could just change at a whim. There is no sense of security with the cards that I play with.
There are a few ways this can easily be addressed without changing the overall plan that you have:
1. Give wild cards to people when a card is changed. (Buffed or nerfed, it does not matter.) This gives people that sense of security where they can spend their wild cards, and if something is changed, its less of a feels bad moment when a card gets nerfed or changed in an undesirable way.
2. Allow players to use either version of the card in their historic decks. (This is easily the best of both worlds here.) Let people play with the cards that they want in whatever version they want, and allow buffed versions of older cards to be playable if you wish. (This obviously does not apply to banned cards like Omnath, where only the changed version is allowed.)
Either of these changes would address the main concern that people have with this update, being that perfectly fine historic cards such as Luminarch Aspirant and Faceless Haven being impacted from standard power level concerns.