My case was similar and maybe it helps to narrow down the possible causes:
I was attacked by Tovolar, a second werewolf and a third creature.
My opponent was allowed to draw 4 cards. - According to my understanding it should have been only 2.
My hypothesis: Since one of my blockers had first-strike, maybe the attack actions were counted twice?
Hope you find the problem with Tovolar, the Midnight scourge.
My case was similar and maybe it helps to narrow down the possible causes:
I was attacked by Tovolar, a second werewolf and a third creature.
My opponent was allowed to draw 4 cards. - According to my understanding it should have been only 2.
My hypothesis: Since one of my blockers had first-strike, maybe the attack actions were counted twice?
Hope you find the problem with Tovolar, the Midnight scourge.
Great game by the may. I enjoy it very much.