My creature did not return to the battlefield as it should have using the card Undying Malice.
My opponent used Lightning Strike to kill my creature and then I played Undying Malice as an instant response. My creature (Evolved Sleeper which had been upgraded to a Phyrexian Human Cleric 3/3) died, but it was not returned to the battlefield. I believe the upgraded form did not take on the ability that it should. Log of the game attached.
My creature did not return to the battlefield as it should have using the card Undying Malice.
My opponent used Lightning Strike to kill my creature and then I played Undying Malice as an instant response. My creature (Evolved Sleeper which had been upgraded to a Phyrexian Human Cleric 3/3) died, but it was not returned to the battlefield. I believe the upgraded form did not take on the ability that it should. Log of the game attached.