Interaction between Kenrith's Transformation and Ashaya, Soul of the Wild
My opponent cast Kenrith's Transformation on my Commander, Ashaya. Ashaya was made a 3/3, but still turned my other nontoken creatures into Forests.

-
PyroArkana#65390 commented
come on men, you have a lot of people telling you about this bug. is important, is very frustrating to play against this type of things
-
AcrylicPickle#43246 commented
I just had this same issue. Kenrith's Transformation's only affect on Ashaya was the 3/3 creature. All other creatures were still lands.
-
Magissorvedor#87692 commented
Same problem
-
Dizzy Backwaters#44531 commented
Still not fixed. I ran into this problem today 2/20/2022.
See attached photos. -
nefarioustoned#08288 commented
1 year on, still not fixed
-
AngelAtheist#52998 commented
This is not a bug, this is actually the correct behavior according to magic rules. Type changing effects happen in layer 4 and ability adding/removing effects happen in layer 6. So the creatures become lands before the ability is removed. Yes, it's weird, layers are confusing.
-
Leopwnz#29088 commented
I used the cardname Kenrith's Transformation in a Ashaya, Soul of the Wild and it supposed to loose all abilites, but the nontokens creatures of my opponent still working like a Forest.
-
AdRam#94417 commented
Kenrith's transformation does not stop all other creatures from being forest when Ashaya is enchanted with it...
-
Loki#57191 commented
i read on a forum, that it is normal based on layers priorities,
https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/layer-system-2009-11-05the guy says "Because type setting is in Layer 4 and ability removal is in Layer 6, Ashaya still turns all my creatures into forests despite losing their abilities."
-
LevDev#93683 commented
There a interesting bug where if you attach kenrith transformation to ashaya, you creatures still stay lands. If ruling right, the not token creatures should stop being lands since ashaya loses here ability with the transformation.
-
LevDev#93683 commented
There a interesting bug where if you attach kenrith transformation to ashaya, you creatures still stay lands. If ruling right, the not token creatures should stop being lands since ashaya loses here ability with the transformation.
-
LevDev#93683 commented
There a interesting bug where if you attach kenrith transformation to ashaya, you creatures still stay lands. If ruling right, the not token creatures should stop being lands since ashaya loses here ability with the transformation.
-
LevDev#93683 commented
There a interesting bug where if you attach kenrith transformation to ashaya, you creatures still stay lands. If ruling right, the not token creatures should stop being lands since ashaya loses here ability with the transformation.
-
PreyingMatis#61051 commented
This has been an issue for months now and still has not been corrected. Ashaya makes all non-token creatures lands even when it looses all abilities.
-
DCSnakepit#37833 commented
Happens with any enchantment that makes Ashaya lose its abilities. Other creatures are still lands.
-
Cr8zy Ivan#09328 commented
I commented on this post in October, and again today (2020-12-18), the Ashaya issue is the same.
-
aryusryan#78366 commented
Kenrith's Transformation said it removed Ashayas abilities but creatures were still entering as lands.
-
flipsix3#25257 commented
Seem to be a lot of bugs around Ashaya - for instance I can't bounce it with into the Roil (because it's not a non-land permanent) yet when someone board-wipes all non-land permanents my Ashaya board gets cleared - either I'm missing something or the definition of n0on-land permanent is not consistent (with Ashaya)
-
Awit#61534 commented
Every time you play Kentrith's Transformation onto Ashaya the only effect is Ashaya's power and toughness is changed to 3/3. It should remove the passive effect as well. The rest of your creatures should not be lands when Kenrith's Transformation is attached to Ashaya. This is specifically a bug as other cards that say they remove all effects of the creature they attach to correctly stop Ashaya's passive.
-
Kithmaker#41254 commented
Screenshot of my (same) experience on my opponent's Ashaya.