Remove Alchemy cardd from Historic/Brawl formats.
I need to express my extreme dissatisfaction with MTGA/WOTC product Alchemy and request that you remove the cards from the historic and brawl formats.
I understand people like Alchemy, and so they should play the Alchemy format. They should not be allowed to dominate other formats with these cards.
I am INCREDIBLY distressed when ever I have to endure this inordinate disadvantage. I feel like all the time I spent building decks is wasted when playing Historic Brawl and a card hits the board that has onboard tutor effects, or allows a player to pull from a wish board/side board - which is illegal in the format.
It's OK that these cards have these effects, just not in Brawl specifically. This example is proof positive that the format has been warped.
Dizzy Backwaters#44531
shared this idea
-
BaronSquirrel#40412
commented
Please let alchemy exist in their own format, the cards are clearly pushed and that is ok, but they should exist separated from the normal pool of cards, playing with and against them is annoying for a lot of the player base, this could be solved by making historic brawl and alchemy historic brawl 2 different formats
-
Gradius9989#54610
commented
I hate this alchemy trash mechanics that cant EVER EXIST. Black red card where we discard hands and seek 7 cards from each others decks is complete fkn ****.
-
popeyedcookie#11448
commented
Agreed losing to an Alchemy card that gave a blue and white deck demonic tutor to win the game is super annoying. Breaks the whole magic logic like *** Wizards why would you even allow this???
(Edited by admin) -
aapielekker#34729
commented
I agree, I play Historic Brawl on MTGA for the same reason I play face to face commander, so if it can't be done in commander, historic brawl should also not be allowed. Maybe give the Alchemy their own brawl format separate from Historic Brawl
-
TheGhostofDackFayden#59569
commented
Congratulations. 14% of games are Alchemy. You haven't broken down just how much of brawl play is Historic Brawl, but with overall Brawl play superseding Alchemy and Historic eclipsing Alchemy by over 10% of total play numbers, I wish you would stop making digital-only designs. It's all that keeps me from resuming Historic play, and I am still absolutely livid you believe it's okay to call Spreading Seas too powerful, and print the digital-only, pub-stomping nonsense you do. I'm still conceding against literally any Alchemy Commander. If I see two Alchemy-only cards played in a row, I'm out. Acknowledge that people hate Alchemy. Stop making excuses.
-
T4tt4#83584
commented
I personally hate alchemy. Is totally useless and that broken cards have to disappear from format like brawl and historic
-
Pastapockets#87184
commented
Alchemy is a failure of a format, but WOTC will never admit to it, so they'll feel forced to keep it around in historic and hbrawl because those are the only played formats where the cards are legal. Wotc additionally hate Brawl players anyway, so they want you to suffer for their incompetence.