Tibalt's Trickery Bugged in Cascade Event
Tibalt's Trickery Bugged in Cascade Event
People are playing a broken trick deck with Tibalt's Trickery and Cultivator Colossus. The reason it's broken is that when a spell cascades into Tibalt's Trickery, and Tibalt's Trickery flips over another Tibalt's Trickery, the player is allowed to retarget the second Tibalt's Trickery and go again until a Cultivator Colossus is flipped.
By rule 701.5, a countered spell should be removed from the stack. By rule 304.2, once an instant has started resolving it must leave the stack. Therefore the Tibalt's Trickery that is found by the first Tibalt's Trickery must have no legal targets and fizzle.
The Cascade event is NOT implementing Tibalt's Trickery correctly and it absolutely ruins the experience.