Why aren't the devs listening to the community?! More than 3/4 of the community absolutely HATES alchemy and it keeps getting pushed outside of its own format, we don't need the stupid mechanics that come with it in Historic or Brawl, nor standard for that matter KEEP IT IN ITS OWN FORMAT.

Conjuring, perpetual, seek. These are all terrible gimmicks that ruin the whole point but I expect nothing better from such a garbage company. This is actually why I quit this game and started playing a better digital game like Hearthstone. I hope WotC goes bankrupt

Alchemy is a cheap cash grab that ruins everything that made historic brawl. This company is garbage and I hope WotC goes bankrupt for their cheap, cashgrabs that force terrible improper cards into this game. Company is dog ****

Remove alchemy ******** cards. They should NOT BE IN OTHER FORMATS. Wtf is the point of historic if alchemy format exists and those heist bs cards can be abused in another format ******** wotc **** sucking pieces of ****. Hope your whole team dies in a fkn fire

Agreed historic was good, and is probably still my favorite format to play, but I have started auto scooping every single time I see an alchemy card because I think alchemy is a cop out. It just makes magic feel like hearthstone to me, and that is not a compliment.

Historic is not historic as it's a made up format containing alchemy cards.

There is also nowhere to play cards for the brand new Modern Horizons 3 set that is not infected with the insane non-paper-mechanics alchemy cards being playable.

I had to verse a commander who conjured the power 9..

There is another mono green commander who conjures free lands.

What is the point of playing Brawl if the core rules aren't followed

Also, they should remove alchemy from Historic brawl, or make its own brawl separate from it so I can stop playing against anything with perpetual and seek in its description or mechanics.
I play MTGA to simulate the paper experience I can no longer afford to play, and these digital only cards with their un-"Magic the Gathering"- like effects are making the format not fun anymore.

I'm really sick of these powerful Alchemy cards, which are allowed to be played in Historic I see being used constantly. Banned cards that were once in Historic such as Teferi Time Raveler, is even more powerful in Alchemy. I once had a fun Historic deck that I enjoyed playing that is constantly being thwarted to heavy used alchemy cards. I've seen many people complain about this and instead it seems you guys shed a blind eye and push alchemy even more. Please do something about this. I don't enjoy playing alchemy, I stopped playing that format, bc of the ridiculousness of how powerful alchemy cards are. And now they are allowed in Historic which is ruining that format for me as well. I might as well go back to collecting hard copies of cards. Please take Alchemy out of Historic. It makes Historic less fun.