Opponent cast sludge monster, which activated its ability on my Sheoldred, the Apocalypse. I used infernal grasp to kill it while the abili
Sheoldred the Apocalypse is treated as a horror by Sludge MOnster.
Steps: 1. opponent summons sludge monster.
2. sludge monster ability goes on stack, targeting my Sheoldred.
3. I cast Infernal Grasp, killing sludge monster while ability is on stack>
4. Ability resolves, giving ***** counter to Sheoldred.
5. Sheoldred gains ***** counter, but retains power, toughness, and all abilities.
Using PC. Unsure about opponent.
I expect the ***** counter to work on Sheoldred, as she does not have "Horror" as a creature type. ***** counter does not work.
No ability to reproduce, as I don't have a friendly player with sludge monster to play with.
-
[Deleted User] commented
Without the Sludge Monster in play, the counter has no effect