Illegal convoke cost paid for Cut Short
Opponent paid for Cut Short only by tapping three mono-green creatures for its Convoke cost.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Player casting Cut Short controls 3 creatures that are green (and no other colors). In my scenario, it is 2 Kami of Whispered Hopes and 1 Renata, Called to the Hunt. This player only controls tapped Forests as land.
2. Cast Cut Short by tapping 3 green creatures.
Expected results: Cut Short is illegal to cast because its white cost cannot be paid.
Actual results: Cut Short is successfully cast.
See attached log from Premier draft.
-
[Deleted User] commented
Kami of Whispered Hopes also has a mana ability to tap for any color of mana. That's where the white mana came from. It wasn't used for convoke.