Hylda of the Icy Crown triggers are not set up correctly
Was playing a game of brawl and discovered this interaction, which according to the ruling on gatherer shouldn't be happening.
Steps to recreate:
Have Hylda and Reservoir Kraken in play
If the opponent chooses to tap their creature, Hylda's ability activates.
This goes contrary to the gatherer rulings for Hylda, which states:
Hylda of the Icy Crown's ability will trigger only when an effect instructs you to tap an opponent's creature. It won't trigger if a spell or ability you control instructs an opponent to tap a creature they control. For example, if you control Tangle Wire and an opponent taps an untapped creature they control as part of the resolution of Tangle Wire's triggered ability, Hylda's ability won't trigger.
-
Brinkmonn#82634 commented
I can confirm this interaction, but this time from my side of the game.