Amelia and Cut Down interaction
1.Amelia is cast, resolves, and enters play.
2.Amelia entering triggers Uneaten Feast.
3.Controller gains 1 life, Amelia triggers and explores a nonland.
4.Opponent casts Shock targeting Amelia, paying the ward cost. Shock resolves.
5.Opponent casts Cut Down with intention of targeting the 3/1 Amelia, except Amelia is not shown as a valid target for Cut Down, and the UI will not allow the player to choose her as a target.
Expected Result:
As Amelia has taken damage this turn reducing her toughness to 1, while having 3 power sums to a total of 4. These stats satisfy the conditions for a valid target for Cut Down.
AbelOfSol#97293
shared this idea
-
DAC169#34537
commented
Doing damage to a creature does NOT reduce its toughness. In this case Amelia is being shown as a 3/1 because she has 3 toughness and 2 points of damage on her, leaving her at 1 "health," i.e. only 1 more damage would be enough to kill her.
If you had wanted to actually kill Amalia, you should have cast Shock or Cut Down before she explored.
-
AbelOfSol#97293
commented
Update: When this bug occurs, inspecting the active Amelia shows the Amelia as still having the stats 3/3. On the field, the active Amelia shows the stats 3/1.