Quina, Qu Gourmet - Frogs gets 1+1 counters when created
I lost a match in Mtg Arena Premier Draft against an opponent who had a Quina, Qu Gourmet on the battlefield and then played the Zanarkand, Ancient Metropolis Adventure side to get a token with 1+1 counters on it for each they control. Doing this should just create a 1/1 frog token but they got a frog with identical 1+1 counters on it, mimicking the land token. They then attacked, i had to block, they then returned the land to their hand, did it again and the same problem occurred.
Metalfist#92187
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Quina, and similar replacement effects that change number and type of tokens created, only changes number and type of tokens created. If the original effect has additional affects to apply to the created token (entering tapped, attacking, with haste, with counters, etc.), that additional effect is applied to ALL tokens created with the modified effect. So, no bug, the Frog has to get the counters.