Same Problem, won 7 Games now with the following deck:

4 Walking Corpse (M21) 128
4 Scathe Zombies (ANB) 59
4 Barony Vampire (M20) 85
4 Thoughtseize (OTP) 20
4 Duress (STA) 29
2 Cast Down (DAR) 81
3 Vicious Offering (DAR) 110
2 Divest (DAR) 87
24 Swamp (AKR) 337
2 Murder (DSK) 110
4 Infernal Grasp (J25) 456
1 Ruinous Path (PIO) 338
2 Drag to the Underworld (THB) 89

Death By Vanilla not working!! Achievement not Working

Same problem here.
Still Bugged :(

>>> I got the achievement playing in Pioneer with:

Deck
1 Yargle and Multani (MOM) 256
8 Forest (DSK) 285
7 Swamp (MKM) 282
4 Yargle, Glutton of Urborg (MUL) 84
4 Rumbling Baloth (ANB) 103
4 Kalakscion, Hunger Tyrant (DFT) 93
4 Jibbirik Omnivore (DFT) 166
1 March of Wretched Sorrow (NEO) 111
4 Galuf's Final Act (FIN) 186
2 Fog (PIO) 346
4 Hard-Hitting Question (MKM) 164
1 Green Sun's Twilight (ONE) 169
1 Deathcap Glade (VOW) 261
4 Haunted Mire (DMU) 248
1 Necroblossom Snarl (STX) 269
4 Temple of Malady (M21) 253
4 Charge Through (STX) 124
1 Great Arashin City (TDM) 257
1 Crawling Barrens (ZNR) 262

It didn't register in Brawl, I won multiple times playing 5 creatures with Terrian, World Tyrant , won with a Sundial, Dawn Tyrant equipment deck and won with a superfriends deck as well

I have the same problem...

Bugged for me also

This is still bugged for me - I have won 3 games where the only creature I cast was Savannah lions, then switched to a RG deck where the only creatures I cast were again vanilla creatures.

Also did not get the achievement after casting >5 vanilla creatures and winning the game.

@BadluckGamma#91185
Confirmed. I cast 5 vanilla creatures, won the game and received the reward.
Hope this ticket helps others!

To those of you coming to this now- they did a TERRIBLE job of explaining this, but you have to cast at least 5 vanilla creatures before you win. You have to hover over the REWARD to even see that.

Still bugged after fix... What creature on this list has an ability?

I have won multiple times with a vanilla set of creatures. Would rather receive the reward based on my log.

Same for me

Same issue here, i have tried with 2 different decks. Once deck is a copy of something online that someone said they completed it with.

Same issue; literally only cast one creature (UW control with the only creature as Caelorna, Coral Tyrant, wins by control and planeswalker stuff) and no achievement.

I also had the same issue. Played a full game only casting Yargle and didn't get the achievement.

Same here. I won a game which fulfilled the requirements twice in my last 5 games. Neither awarded me the achievement. Since it's a stupid grind, I would prefer to receive the achievement from support based on my logs, if possible.
2025.51.20.3396.1177291

had the same issue on pc version 2025.51.20.9661.1177291

Same thing happened to me on mobile version 2025.51.20.3099.1177291
Logs would not download.