bug?
opponent had toph the first metal bender i cast eaten by piranhas enchanting toph making it loose all abilities but new artifacts cast by opponent were still entering as lands even thou toph lost all abilities when they should only enter as artifacts
froggerpirate999#00342
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Not a bug, no. Due to how the layer system of applying continuous effects works, type changes ALWAYS happen before ability losing, regardless of the time stamps of the effects. So the artifacts become lands before Toph loses her abilities. The same applies to a lot of other cards, too, like Kudo, Kaito, Ashaya, Ygra, etc. If there is a type change or color change or anything else in the effect that applies before layer 6 (where ability losing happens), that effect gets applied first. And continues to apply other parts of its effects, too, even if the ability is lost by the time those parts get applied (rule 613.6).