Indestructible Bug
There is a bug in the game that has been present for over a year now.
there is a card named, Chittering Witch, it is a mono black (3b mana value) 2/2.
Its ability states, Pay 1B: sacrifice a creature: target creature get -2/-2 Until end of turn.
the issue is that this card will not kill creatures that have been granted indestructible with an instant speed spell and will not kill creatures that have already been dealt damage.
the thing is other creatures that have Indestructible natively Chittering Witch has no issue killing.
ex. Kotis she can and will kill with her activated ability.
ex. if someone uses Boros charm or something similar to make their creature indestructible she will not kill it.
ex. if i attack into a creature with indestructible and then use Chittering witch to assign -2/-2 she will not kill that creature.....
this has been a bug for well over a year now.... i would really appreciate if it is address. i have lost numerous games due to this bug.
Tripps_on_Knives#14970
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Combining damage with -X/-X effects cannot kill indestructible ctreatures. Damage does not reduce tougnness, so when the already damaged creature gets its toughness reduced with -X/-X, it is slightly less tough with damage marked on it. But only if the -X to toughness can bring down the tougness to 0 or less (and damage cannot help with that) will the indestructible creature die.