Product Suggestion
Title: Proposal: Optional “Timed Queue” (Chess Clock Mode) for MTG Arena
Overview
I’d like to propose an optional game mode in MTG Arena called “Timed Queue”, designed for players who prefer a consistent and efficient pace of play. This mode would use a shared time system (similar to a chess clock) to reduce intentional slow play while leaving existing formats unchanged.
Core Concept
Timed Queue would be an opt-in playlist where each player has a shared total time bank for the entire match.
Each player receives ~5 minutes total match time
All actions draw from that player’s clock
When a player’s time reaches zero, they lose (or auto-pass priority)
This ensures players are accountable for their pace without impacting others.
Key Benefits
Eliminates repeated roping: Prevents players from stalling turn after turn without consequence
Improves overall experience: Appeals to players who value efficient, respectful gameplay
Encourages skill expression: Rewards game knowledge and decisiveness
Fully optional: Does not affect new or casual players in standard queues
Anti-Abuse Safeguards
Track clock expirations (when a player runs out of time)
Repeated expirations within a short window trigger a temporary lockout from Timed Queue
Players are redirected to standard queues during cooldown
This targets repeat behavior without punishing occasional disconnects.
Optional Enhancements
Small time increment per action (e.g., +2–3 seconds) to smooth gameplay
Reconnect grace period for brief disconnects
Potential Ranked Timed Queue for competitive players
Why This Matters
Intentional slow play and excessive roping can significantly degrade the MTG Arena experience. Current systems allow enough flexibility that some players exploit them, leading to frustration and disengagement.
An optional Timed Queue would provide a space where:
Time is respected
Gameplay flows naturally
Players can choose a faster, more competitive environment
Closing Thought
This proposal is about adding choice, not replacing existing systems. A Timed Queue would offer a better experience for players who value pace, while preserving accessibility for everyone else.