Banishing betrayal on a creature with counter made it permanently stuck on board
- I control a Noxious Newt with a +1/+1 counter on it
- I attack with my Noxious Newt
- Opponent casts Banishing Betrayal targeting Noxious Newt during the combat step
Expected result: opponent resolves their spell and Noxious Newt returns to my hand
Actual result: opponent resolves their spell, the +1/+1 counter is removed from the Newt, but it is not returned to my hand. It is stuck on the battlefield, tapped, with no counters, and power/toughness is 2/3.
1
vote
Artem#93190
shared this idea