Ashaya keeps creatures as lands after being turned into Treasure Token with Vraska
Ashaya Soul of the Wild was turned into a treasure token by Vraska, Betrayal's Sting. All my opponents' creatures in play and the ones played afterwards are still registering as lands. Screenshot for proof.
.png){kind=link}
Wise#11622
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Not a bug. This is the interaction of layers of continuous effects. Type changing effects happen in layer 4 while ability losing happens in layer 6. Since effects are applied in the order of the layers, Ashaya and all other effects that include a type change (like Magus of the Moon, Kaito, Kudo, and many others) always happen before the ability creating the effect is removed. They always win out over ability losing effects. And due to rule 613.6, once an effect starts to apply, it gets to apply fully, even if parts of the effect happen after the ability creating the effect is removed.