She-Hulk, Jade Defender Bug
Good day, just had a draft game in which i found a bug with card She Hulk Jade Defender, i played her and instantly activated powerup ability to kill artifact my opponent controled and also get a +1+1 counter.
My opponent flickered the artifact in response with Wiccan so i couldnt kill it, thats okay but considering on She Hulk text says ,,destroys up to one artifact,, and in next sentence put +1+1 counters on She Hulk i think putting +1+1 counters should still activate considering it has ,,up to one,, and its not necesarry needed to kill artifact with it, especially if its possible to activate powerup ability without any artifact or enchantment on the board and putting +1+1 counters this way still works.
WotC_VNDR_Jessie#07208
shared this idea
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Like all spells and abilities where a target is selected, if all targets have become illegal by the time it resolves, NONE of its effects happen. So while the +1/+1 counter is not depending on the artifact being destroyed, it is depending on the ability actually resolving. Which it didn't because, it fizzled. If you want to make sure to get the +1/+1 counter, you have to forgo choosing a target.