Surgical extraction exiles a card on the stack
An opponent used Surgical Extraction as a counterspell. I cast Scale Up and the opponent responded by casting Surgical Extraction targeting the Scale Up in my graveyard. The Scale Up on the stack was exiled did not resolve.
Rule 601.2 states that once a spell has been put on the stack it is no longer in hand. Surgical Extraction should not have exiled the card from the stack.
1
vote
MuadDib_Usul#81939
shared this idea