Moonshadow
When a token dies, it goes to the graveyard. Moonshadow gets a -1/-1 counter removed when this happens. Your game does not see that actually happening. Super shredder, however, sees all tokens go to the graveyard and gets buffed.
What?? I'm in a bad mood and having nothing nice to say today. This sucks that I can't trust your game to play the game.
1
vote
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Moonshadow gets a counter removed, when a permanent CARD goes to your graveyard. Tokens aren't cards. Tokens are permanents, though, so Super Shreddder sees them leaving the battlefield.