Algorithm Improvement
I'm sure you're getting a lot of complaints about how one-sided your algorithm is not being impartial and often times screwing over players with land draws that should not be happening in a purely random sample - so my complaint can be added to that pile.
But, an idea for changing the algorithm to improve randomization would be having the program assign a number to each card remaining in a deck and pile shuffling the cards into X amount of piles (let's say 6). It can repeat this process Y amount of times then take the middle of the pile and put those cards on top. A better template would be from the card shuffler for poker sets from stores.
-
Bosque#76556 commented
I almost always play against black decks that cast Thoughtseize on turn one (this card should be banned in explorer due to its high power for the format for one mana but woc seems to love this color) or board sweepers and my experience is quite frustrating as mono green player (currently incredibly weak archetype that hasn't been improved in recent years and now it's time)
The "bad luck" obtained with really bad hands or steals (if I mulligan it's worse) doesn't help either while the opponents have the perfect answers in most games makes me quite suspicious. They almost never have to mulligan, if they do, no more than twice as I often have to do, and their decks seem to go extremely well against mine.
It happens so often most days and I've been playing for over a year, I guess my account is rigged.
If in reality the color black is so popular, it is a clear indication that they have to nerf this color a little but I suppose it is the company's favorite.
People realize how rigged it is and I think it's time for them to impose some internal algorithm to create more fun and equal games.
In the meantime, I don't recommend taking this game seriously to anyone. -
Dime#13001 commented
I want to suggest that you fix the shuffler. It can´t be, that I draw 11 lands in the first 14 cards... see screenshot. And it doesn´t happen once in a million games.
-
Serkian#23585 commented
Add to that that you have in a mononet 20 lands 17 basic 3 rare. 3 games in a row in hand 2 of the 3 rares in the hand hahahahahahahaha it's not rigged right?
-
Serkian#23585 commented
How about you fix your shuffling system? I don't find it quite funny that from a deck with 24 lands in a standard event in 4 consecutive games you draw only two from the initial hand and for 5 turns 0 lands, added to the fact that coincidentally in the 5th game of a deck with 24 lands By chance you steal the 4 paidlands against a monoredburn, it's all quite a coincidence but hey, keep making money from skins and **** and don't fix your system, which is not rigged at all, and only helps the people who pay for things in life. you face decks with skins on each card and coincidentally they don't float, they don't have miss lands and they curve each card perfectly, lest the 3 billion that you pocket each quarter be enough, and you continue screwing the f2p and new players, without events so they can get gold, with ****** missions that give you 500/750 gold a day (if you're lucky), without events to learn how to play draft with a pass that gives you only 1200 gems out of 3400, (pretty absurd when In the rest of the games they refund the cost of the pass, they are not rats like here).
-
Sliver_87#24002 commented
I played today against a deck with 80 or more cards. He get's every card he or she need. It can't be a good balance that card with more than sixty cards get better draws so finally and totaly too late fix the dam shuffler. How it ti spossible that a player with a sixty card deck get punished and worse draws with a bigger deck and lower chances. Or just limited the deck Size for example nobody can play more than 65 cards, except companion or in general says other things. In addition exlude no mana hands and more than three mana hands tochosse from as an AI. Your are digital try new things, change things that don't make fun and you can't do it paper.
-
Durendal#68785 commented
Your shuffler needs immediate improvements, because it's widely unfair. About half of the matches are unplayable for screwing, flooding and very stranges card draw's odds. Is pretty common to draw the same card four times in a row and it's pretty common to draw ten lands over 20 in the firsts 20 cards of the deck.
Please, fix it. From this depends the playability itself and the quality of Arena. -
Necrecon#36471 commented
Do yourself a favor and uninstall this ****ing pathetic excuse for a card game now. Has-beens of the Cost don't care about good game mechanics. They don't care about things being even. They don't care about the player base. What they care about is getting as much money out of you as possible before whoever steps up to be in charge next runs the rest of this dumpster fire into the ground. Don't play this game and for God's sake if you do DO NOT pay for anything. Play a better card game like Pokemon or YuGioh or gamble your kid's college funds away. Anything but this.
-
CanTebdo#16316 commented
Recently I reported on the mana flood and mana ***** problem that occurs in 1/3 of games, the answer I was given is that the draw algorithm works great, now I don't know how you tested it or if you have ever played Magic but a situation like this only happens if you have 30 or more lands I play 20 and out of 16 cards I drew 9 lands, And you know, it's not nice if the algorithm decides who gets to win and who doesn't...
-
Haystack#90070 commented
Just played 20 straight games where my opponent totally destroyed me. Each card they played was the perfect foil to each card I played. They were like a well oiled machine making quick work of a lesser obstacle.
Then I played 20 straight games where I totally destroyed my opponent. Each card I played was the perfect foil to each card they played. I was like a well oiled machine making quick work of a lesser obstacle.
None of the games were fun
-
YODA#37534 commented
Please fix the **** MTGO shuffler too. ******* horrible
-
DaddyMac#12236 commented
Y. My stats show that the algorithm is either horrible or the site is rigged. Don't they do periodic studies on the algorithm to see if it works right? How can you run a site with such a flawed algorithm?
-
DaddyMac#12236 commented
I do not go first anywhere near 50% of the time. I have kept detailed track for a long time now. That means that there is either a serious issue with the software or there is cheating (similar to what the poker sites were doing). I have reported the problem but Arena does nothing. I am in the process of filing a class action law suit against Wizards. If you have experienced the same problem, pleas contact me.
-
ehle#32097 commented
Why is it that opponent can go first (on the play) upward of 8+ games in a row. It doesn't matter what queue or game type I am in. I find i am only ever going 2nd in games for long periods. This makes the game unfair and more unenjoyable. I feel a problem with the queue or algorithm for how games are matched up.
-
ARivasII89#76709 commented
Love watching opponents being able to entirely eliminate the element of luck from Magic!Drawing nothing but pressure and perfect answers to EVERY card I play, on perfect curve!
Not one point of damage on my opponent, when I’m on the ******* play! Only on Arena
Stop ******* rigging games, ********.
-
ARivasII89#76709 commented
Spent $400 to start playing on MTGO and its the best ******* decision I've made. My deck actually plays like my ******* deck.
No more ******** hands with no more than two lands and manipulative card draws.
Came to Arena to test the waters again and you all did not disappoint.
First game, no green mana. Second game, SIX green mana sources and ZERO red, with only a red card in hand. **** this piece of **** app you've created.
-
RJCOOL7#34658 commented
Queueing into the same opponent multiple times in a row during draft events, particularly premier and traditional drafts is foolish. The entry is 1500 gems which is approximately 10 dollars. The prize for going 3-0 is 2500 or about 15 dollars, 2-1 1000 about 6.75 all approximately. When you are literally competing for money playing against the same opponent multiple times in a row feels terrible. If you win great twice great but you are moving up the bracket and essentially scrub your opponent out to no gain. If you go 1-1 you no cost yourself breaking even or winning at all. Put some fails safes in to stop that. Or better yet make a phantom queue with a smaller entry fee. Least of all don't send your lackies to tell me to post on the forum, looking at you Daniel...
"Hello,
Thank you for reaching out with your concern. To avoid long queue times, you'll sometimes play against the same opponent. If you would like to share your opinion about this feature please do so here. In that forum, which is also where you go to report and upvote bugs, you and other players can create new feedback entries, and upvote each others' entries if you feel they reflect your own experiences and suggestions. This feedback is reviewed directly by the Arena development team.
I’ll be glad to help you further if you have any other questions or concerns!Daniel
Wizards of the Coast | Customer Service Representative
Email support is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week here." -
planeswalker green#15792 commented
game log
-
planeswalker green#15792 commented
i have a 60 card deck with 24 land in it the first 24 cards i draw 11 are land. this doesn't happen in real life. how is it i can draw 10 land in the first 16 cards i draw. that's almost half my deck in lands. this is impossible by odds problem with your programing. im on steam and updated windows. if this isnt fixed soon i refuse to play anymore. its not fun when you have to give up every 3 games because you draw anywhere from 8 to 10 lands in a row. fix this now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Tekkchi#39447 commented
It's time to fix the not so randomness of card draw.. Seriously regardless the deck you use its clear chances of winning are predetermined based statistically impossibilities that occur during a match. Its creates unenjoyable match playing when you understand your are not winning because of the skill of your play rather the algorithm has determined its your turn to lose...... Come on Wizards randomizing shouldn't be this hard
-
いんぱち#37346#72039 commented
以下の三点について改善を要求します。
・初手札の明らかな偏りとマリガン誘発
・デッキタイプの相性が悪い敵とのマッチアップ確率の増加
・良手札に見せかけて相手に完全にコントロールされるパターン