Gisa, Maskwood, Rampage, Sacrifice, Exile Failure to return to Board
“Gisa, Glorious Resurrector” is not returning cards to the battlefield.
Specifically, in a game alongside “Rampage of the Valkyries” and “Maskwood Nexus” (against ****** white).
Turn after turn, using the effects of the above to trigger the sack effect of Rampage, after which Gisa would cause the enemies cards to be exiled, but not returned to the board on my turn as she is supposed to.
Her “trigger effect card” would come up at the appropriate time, but fail to return the non-token creature permanents she had previously exiled.
This went on for 3-4 turns before the game ended.
Not once did the game function properly in this respect.
-
TheTechMan#38475 commented
If the opponent also ran Liisa, Forgotten Angel, the creature gets exiled, but gets returned to the owner at the end of their end step (which is before your upkeep), so it goes back to them.