Product Suggestion Leave Historic Alone
With the new Alchemy format, can we please have it separated from Historic? You are going to be nerfing cards considering the standard environment, please leave them alone for Historic decks.
-
lordi_erez#59300 commented
also #leavehistoricalone
-
lordi_erez#59300 commented
wotc, please leave historic alone
this game is one of the only reasons i havb't hanged myself yet (the other two reasons ae my dog and the fact that there is no coffee after death)
-
future_sommelier#79760 commented
Please leave a historic paper only queue.
-
LeDiableBlanc#96819 commented
Saved multiple WCs so I can get on to Historic and this bull is welcoming me?
GTFO!! -
Nephilim#62602 commented
#leavehistoricalone
-
Hellblazer#22231 commented
New formats are welcome, but don't ruin the existing ones. No rebalanced only versions of cards in Historic. Leave our format alone!
#leavehistoricalone -
Tnesniv Yorel#28339 commented
Please let Historic be a place similar to paper, and let Alchemy be the only place that truly behaves like a digital card game. Many play Arena because they want to play magic on a more regular basis, and they don't want to have Arena behave like a different card game.
Another major issue is that some cards may be powerful for Standard, but not or barely powerful enough for historic. Using the same card in both historic and Alchemy will risk making those cards absolutely unplayable in historic.
-
Gero30#34241 commented
Rebalancing cards that are perfectly fine for Historic Is a big mistake. While Aspirant and Goldspan Dragon are powerful cards they don't need a nerf for Historic. It also makes no sense to have a Goldspan Dragon stronger in Standard than in a non rotating format.
I think that editing a card on the go is a lazy excuse to retcon some poor design decisions at the expense of the players and it's also confusing to keep track of what a paper card does and in what it's digital doppelganger differs.
If this Is what you envision for Historic than just give us a digital eternal format, playable in paper with a modern interface. Please.
-
Kaarn#65193 commented
Alchemy by itself = fine idea
Forcing it into historic which was advertised as a non rotating format = terrible idea that will alienate a huge portion of the playerbase. Aka, almost every single historic player. -
lasagnaman#17890 commented
#leavehistoricalone
-
ZindZyg#10528 commented
#leavehistoricalone
-
alexm#36939 commented
#leavehistoricalone !
#leavehistoricthefuckalone ! Greedy Dumbasses -
Elicasa#68051 commented
leave historic alone, no rebalancing please and also Modern on Arena
-
Aardschok#11040 commented
Make alchemy a fully separate mode. With arena only card. Historic, pure paper rules
-
D8y#43311 commented
Stop this nonsense, please.
-
Crypto#02787 commented
leave historic alone, no rebalancing please and also Modern on Arena
-
Cathardigan#51945 commented
The biggest problem with this change is it devalues historic as a competitive format. No other competitive format has live balancing. Historic players want to feel like they're competing just like every other player. Please. Please don't do this.
-
kalpof#45861 commented
Please, leave the unbalanced cards in historic, it's basically killing the format
-
Myriadtail#27098 commented
They banned Cat/Oven because the triggers were "too clunky for players to handle" but not a word about them in historic.
Yet they will cite that players will be "confused by multiple versions of a card" in Historic, even though there will be different versions between Alchemy and Standard.
Curious. -
archiel#52516 commented
I hope people finally start showing their dissatisfaction with their wallets, because it's the only way you'll listen. This is a horrible idea, and could've been easily "fixed" before it got to full fruition, if you've just reached out to community, or a few select members of it.
I'm not against digital only cards, but probably of them being easily "balanced" makes me not to want to dip my toes into Alchemy at all. If I got some cards for free, sure, but spending on Boosters and using up WCs is a big no-no for me.
Alchemy isn't that of a horrible idea, but it being part of Historic is, it should be a separate format from Historic.