Product Suggestion Leave Historic Alone
With the new Alchemy format, can we please have it separated from Historic? You are going to be nerfing cards considering the standard environment, please leave them alone for Historic decks.
-
nosound#73855 commented
Now important influencers on Houtube are going against you…how can you keep ignoring all this?
-
LucasLara#66898 commented
LEAVE. HISTORIC. ALONE.
I want an eternal format.
Hells, I would drop so much cash if you could just bring pioneer and merge it to Historic.Stop this digital-only non-sense and let us play MAGIC.
-
Philosoranen#72479 commented
I really don’t have a way to play in person, so I play on Arena. Now that Historic has these Alchemy cards, it’s really not Magic, so I really don’t have a place to play anymore. I’m not interested in playing cards that are only available on Arena. I can’t bring myself to spend any more time or money on this game until Alchemy gets out of Historic and Rebalanced goes away entirely.
Whoever came up with this idea should be fired immediately. In the future, anything that isn’t available on paper should be completely optional in Arena. Also, try spending your time working through all your glitches for a while.
Side note: Your new UI sucks. It’s like you intentionally tried to make it more confusing.
-
gsm.1808#46999 commented
I still don't understand the point of adding alchemy, and even less so of changing cards in Historic according to that horrible, sad excuse for a "product". Do you purposefully want to sabotage Arena and Historic?
-
HarrietTubgirl#79416 commented
Please leave Historic alone, this is such an obvious cash grab for you guys.
-
Alaheim#47948 commented
Not touching Arena (outside maybe a little standard while I still have relevant cards) until this garbage call Alchemy is removed or modified into a separate stand alone format
-
RichardKarnLiberated#71992 commented
I don’t accept the change you have made to Historic by replacing existing cards with modified Alchemy versions of these same cards. I won’t play again unless this changes.
-
KingFungus#07836 commented
Please limit card changes to Alchemy named formats.
-
Devinorium#93061 commented
Make historic great again!
-
Knull#45470 commented
Please leave historic alone
-
Tygerburningbright#30581 commented
Changes made based on standard levels of balance should not be carried over to Historic. Furthermore, the lack of a 1 to 1 compensation for changes to cards is unacceptable.
-
Skeith Zero#56461 commented
Either ban the cards in historic and refund wildcards, then introduce the nerfed versions. or don't put the changed cards in historic. the only changed cards that should exist in historic are already digital only or cards previously banned.
-
Perpleximon#42038 commented
Please let Historic be an eternal format and not one that has to shift due to rebalancing. :/
-
Hehagardenhoe#11634 commented
The only reason I haven't uninstalled, is because I'm sure you'll end up reversing this due to backlash.
Seriously though, you had a perfectly good tool, that could be targeted to single formats, known as Bannings... But instead of using that (and also learning from your mistakes on extra turn cards: AS IN, stop printing them!), you invent a new format (Alchemy), and screw with a second one (Historic), and avoid fixing the third one (Standard).
It's not hard to figure out some of the issues... Every time you make an extra turn card, it becomes either an issue, or a deck people build to troll others.
I don't play MTG Arena for these new formats... I play them as placeholders for when you finally finish adding all the pioneer cards, and figure out how to do multi-player commander!
-
ihlenfeldt#94051 commented
I can't justify reinstalling Arena after removing it due to the restrictive costs associated with historic. I used to spend a great deal on Arena but cannot justify it if my cards are suddenly going to be worthless with no recourse.
-
febrr#15571 commented
Those Cards are so annoying.
They not only ***** with Historic as a format, but with the very fabric of the game itself.
Who was asking for ******* perpetual abilities on ******* cards in hands, decks and graveyards?Just take that trash and put it in some alchemystoric kindergarden right next to the alchemy standard one.
-
LadyZoe#34145 commented
How historic is handled will determine whether I keep arena installed. I'm starting to wonder if Magic is still for me
-
ChickenTendies.zip#26757 commented
This was the worst idea. If I'd have known you were going to nerf cards I wouldn't have spent wildcards on them. Alchemy AND Historic or Historic only!
-
Helldozer#95207 commented
Making Alchemy nerfs the same in historic as they are in standard is like banning lightning bolt in modern because it's too good for standard. It's literally the dumbest decision I've ever seen and I've been playing the game since Odyssey block...
Let me play Alchemy but also LET ME PLAY HISTORIC. They are two incredibly different formats and for them to have the same "nerf list" is absolutely brain dead.
-
SilverSwag#59848 commented
Alchemy should be the only format with rebalanced paper cards, leave them out of historic.
Historic should be paper cards as printed + the digital only cards.