I agree as well, please remove Alchemy from Historic Brawl, Alchemy should have its own Brawl format separate from Historic Brawl. I play the Historic Brawl as a paper/tabletop replacement, and Alchemy does not exist in paper/tabletop so should not exist in Historic Brawl, give it it's own format, Alchemy Brawl or something.

100% agree with this. It ruins matches for me and the other player. I leave as soon as a "draft" card is played. If their commander is an alchemy card, I leave. If they make cards out of the either, I leave. I hate it and refuse to play with them. I was ok with the idea of re-balancing cards with alchemy but not this.

Please, we are not asking to ban alchemy, just create a separate brawl format for it, playing against them feels always unfair and many players who don't enjoy alchemy and refuse to add them to their decks like me because we simply don't enjoy the nature of alchemy end up having a bad experience, I understand that the alchemy cards have to be pushed so people can like them and that is fine,but please don't force us to use them if we don't enjoy them

This makes me less likely to buy paper products because I can't do any real test run online to try to tune decks. WoTC is legit failing to get some of my earnings because there isn't any online avenue for playing against real decks, just these stupid decks with perpetual effects.

Alchemy cards are blatantly unfair. There is a commander who gives you the power 9 (banned cards in all formats) to your hand, a commander that copies the lands you play, cards that give you cards that aren't in your deck or side board.

What are you meant to do against these cards when you are playing legitiment cards. The only alternative to compete is to play these types of cards which makes the game generally unfun and unenjoyable.

Please leave alchemy cards to their own format.

I hate alchemy and I hope that Arena will slowly work towards a real commander format with 100 cards and multiplayer. When that finally happens I deeply hope alchemy cards aren't in that format or I will refuse to play it. I only play against real magic cards.

I just insta concede whenever I see an alchemy card. Sad that at least 40% of my games end that way. Here is hoping I won't have to do this forever.

Alcamy was already bad for historic brawl the addition of lord of the rings cards have made alot of decks no longer viable, the ability to make your win con unblockable and win reliability on turn 5 means 4/5/6/7 drop commanders can no longer be played

Unfortunately wizards will never do this because alchemy is a stupid embarassment and HBrawl is one of the only formats it sees play.