Bug re Blade of Shared Souls Copying Creature Enchanted with Planar Disruption
Today I was playing a match of [ONE] quick draft.
I had a 9/9 Trawler drake on field (i.e. the drake, plus 8 counters). It was enchanted with planar disruption.
I played 'Blade of Shared Souls' and attempted to copy the drake.
This then caused the token to be immediately destroyed.
This meant that the blade went to the side, unequipped.
I then tried to equip the blade to an 'escaped experiment' - same result.
I believe this is a bug. I believe I should have received a 9/9 copy of my drake when I first resolved the blade of shared souls.
I strongly believe that this bug cost me the game as I did not get a 9/9 flyer which would have been overwhelmingly superior to anything else on board.
My opponents hand was empty by the time they won the game. They had no other removal.
My user named is 1nverted.
I was playing a Jeskai artifacts deck.
I would like a refund of the 5,000 gold I paid for this quick draft.
-
[Deleted User] commented
Your 2/2 rebel token from the For Mirrodin effect of the Blade has no oil counters, neither does the Escaped Experiment. Turning either into a copy of a base 0/0 creature that gets a buff through oil counters on it makes them 0/0 s getting no buff. Thus they die for having 0 or less toughness. Counters and other things affecting a permanent are not copied with copy effects. Only previous copy effects and other effects applied in layer 1 modify copiable values and thus can be copied. The game handled this correctly.