Scorching Dragonfire on Brutal Cathar
I cast Brutal Cathar and took my opponent's only creature. As I targeted the creature, my opponent responded with a Scorching Dragonfire which should have killed the Brutal Cathar and ultimately: had his creature return. The Scorching Dragonfire went off and nothing happened. My Brutal Cathar was untouched and his creature was still exiled underneath it.
-
ilovebraisedmeats#57802 commented
Was the Cathar transformed into Moonrage Brute? If so, they may not have paid the ward cost. Other possible explanations would be if Cathar had ward from another source or if you had a damage reduction effect in play allowing the Cathar to survive.
-
[Deleted User] commented
Did you have Rem Karolus in play? Or something else giving protection?