Deanna Troi, Psychic Counsel
This card is worded incredibly poorly. You caused me a loss in a draft because the way this card functions does not follow from the actual wording of the card.
The card reads
"Other creatures you control enter with an additional 1+1 counter on them."
The card is giving everything 1+1 counters when they enter, regardless as to whether the creature naturally enters the battlefield with a counter or not.
However, if the card does not come with counters on it enters the battlefield, there should be no counters added, because additional means and implies at least 1+1 counter required for the trigger to occur. If the card read
"Other creatures you control enter with a 1+1 counter on them." it would be clearer and not lead to this ambiguity in the rules. Additional implies in order to get the counter, your card naturally must already enter with counters on it. Or write in this a box around the text since this is going very much against how people would normally understand this card.
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
Your proposed wording would cause confusion with cards that do already enter with counters. If a creature naturally enters with two counters, and your card says it enters with one, how many does it enter with? The "additional" is nessessary. And an additional counter to zero counters is one counter. The game of Magic has handled these effects like this at least since 6th edition.