All we want is a truly random shuffle and draw system, just like in paper Magic.
All we want is a truly random shuffle and draw system, just like in paper Magic.
Stop manipulating our opening hands. Stop using hand-smoothing algorithms. Stop interfering with the natural randomness of the game.
We want to play Magic as it was designed to be played: with genuinely random shuffling, dealing, and draws. Let the cards fall where they may. Let the players decide the outcome.
No artificial adjustments. No hidden interventions. Just genuine randomness.
Is that really too much to ask?
-
naruto#88542
commented
@Rezzahan
Thank you for the detailed explanation and for sharing your experience. I appreciate you taking the time to explain your perspective. It's given me something to think about. Thanks again!
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
I know, that the opening hand is preselected by an algorithm from several options, the criteria of which I do not know. Wizards has stated as much.
What I meant, is that people are using their paper Magic experience as a yard stick for proper randomization, and that is wrong, because the manual shuffle is at best sufficient, and not at all uniformly random. So of course true uniform randomization, or the pseudo-random computer derived RNG for a uniform randomization, will differ notably from your paper experience. Because fringe permutaions of the library are happening more often due to manual shuffling having a heavy bias towards the mean, or "normal" draws.
Furthermore, people are building their decks based on their paper Magic experiences and guidelines. Most notably, the land count. 40% land is fine when there is that heavy bias towards average draws due to the manual shuffle. But 40% is not nearly enough when uniform randomizaion is used. When you want to consistently play a land for the first 4-5 turns, then the proper land count is closer to 47%. So 47 lands in 100 cards deck (brawl), or 26-27 lands in a normal constructed 60 card deck. And those numbers have worked for me through countless games, way better than the accepted 40% guideline.
-
naruto#88542
commented
Rezzahan,
Are you saying that you believe MTG Arena's current shuffling and drawing system is working properly?
I understand that manual shuffling in paper Magic cannot guarantee mathematically perfect randomization. But that's a separate issue from whether Arena's algorithms are introducing artificial adjustments to opening hands or draws.
I'm asking whether you believe Arena's current system provides genuinely random and fair gameplay.
-
Rezzahan#77802
commented
As if the manual shuffle would be truly random. It is at best "sufficient", as in no player knows where any given card has ended up. But a true uniform randomization you cannot get with it.