Why can't we have a nonrotating Brawl format, that is free of Alchemy? Why must a fun game of Brawl be ruined by some absolutely broken Alchemy cards? The Brawl format gets polluted more and more with those unfun cards. Alchemy is NOT fun. Even WINNING with Alchemy cards is not fun. You prove that to me Every Single Time an Into the Future Midweek Magic event comes about. From its inception on, win or lose, not a single game of Alchemy was fun.

I'm not asking to remove Alchemy from Brawl, but rather I'm asking for a different eternal Brawl format. I would happily take the less expansive card pool of Pioneer, with non-rebalanced versions of cards, for example. I know, from this very platform here, that I'm not alone with my grief over Alchemy cards. Why do you insist on forcing Alchemy on your Brawl players? People who engage in Alchemy already dump their money into it. Those that don't care about Alchemy won't spend any money on it, no matter how hard you push. Until they leave your game completely, not buying anything.