Getting a good hand is like pulling teeth in this game.

I can't even begin to tell you how many times I've gone through mulligans to get a better starting hand just to end up with one type of mana and 5 cards of the opposite mana color in a two color deck.

I have at least one match per day where I'll draw nothing but mana (mana clumps in a digital card game) 5+ turns in a row. Decks that I've made it pretty far with in Ranked are completely hindered by a bad first hand.

This card game is older than my parents and it still hasn't figured out a meaningful way of dealing with poor mana distribution. It feels like whatever department is assigned to iterating on the mechanics is completely empty and the employees that are listed in said department don't actually exist. They're just on paper to make the players feel better. It's baffling that, even on my cell phone or PC, an algorithm can't properly sort my cards evenly. You either play mono-color decks or just lose 50% of your games to bad draws. I literally concede 50% of my games to bad first draws and mulligans that seem impossibly poor.

Here's a great idea: Give me two piles. One for all the cards that do something and another pile for my mana. It'll force the player to make the strategic decision whether to draw more cash to spend on cards or skip mana for a meaningful draw.

I play Alchemy primarily, so one bad draw or three consecutive turns of drawing absolutely nothing in such a fast-paced format absolutely ruins the experience and makes me utterly despise the game and everyone who likes it. Just let me decide if I need to draw mana and forgo a valuable draw or if I need more firepower next turn. Try it out as a feature in Alchemy only. I don't care. Just try this solution or, frankly, any meaningful solution to mana clumps. Please. For the love of Christ. Do. Anything.

P.S. I stopped writing this, played one game and immediately got a mana clump. Right after complaining. Thanks.

ミシック相手ですら、
手札がよるのは、うんざり。

22/64が土地のデッキで、
8/12が土地。

わざとだろ。

try to make a causal format that has the deck sizes on par like one 60 card deck max then a 61 to 100 card deck min max the same for 200 and 250 so if you make a fun deck it is matchup against similar deck and not a 60 card burn deck vs a 250 combo deck and you just sit there and are a target for them

I'm coming across an issue that has happened with some frequency. If I share cards with my opponent ,meaning that both players have one or more cards that each player has in their deck, I will not pull those cards during the match. I am submitting two screenshots the first is the game table, the second is the list of lands in the deck I used in that match. I have seven cards in my hand with white mana and I have 8 plains and 8 other combo lands with white mana. My opponent white mana only. Yes I lost that match but it happens way too often that my hand lacks what my opponent has in theirs.

boa tarde! parem de manipular o jogo. quando eu ganho mais de 3 partidas o jogo fica zicando os terrenos ( nao vem terrenos) voces da wizards tem que rever esse problema de travarem o nosso jogo. deixem o jogo fluir ok

25 lands in a deck. Can't get the 4th land by 12 cards 9 of past ten games.

SetLands ratio (25/60): .4166666667 (.4) for simplicity
IF 3 lands out of 9(.33) cards is less than .4 THEN draw land.
IF 5 lands out of 9 cards(.55) cards is greater than .4 THEN draw a nonland.

Simple ******* basic (learn within 2 weeks of first class of programming) is better than the donkey **** your paid programmers come up with.

YOU CAN LITERALLY PROGRAM THIS THING TO HAVE AWESOME GAMES AFTER AWESOME GAMES BECAUSE NOONE GETS LAND****.

Instead its, oh, you have 4 losses, in a row, time to have a perfect hand while your opponent gets ******. That isnt fun for anyone.

I'll build a **** deck right now, literal ****, and it will win its first 5 out of 6 games because you want new decks from possibly new players to keep playing... You are not promoting the game, you're ******* off regulars with reasonable decks forcing landfucks. That kind of horse **** is impeding real growth and progress.

You might say "I'm sorry to ear that you have a bad game today bla bla bla". I'd say, fix your Fxxxxxg RNG. i literally did 3 draft today that i bought with gems, and it was like scripted. Every signle game i get mana ***** because, you know IT'S MAGIC. But ffs, in these 3 draft i didn't win any single game, and i'm not a ****** bronze trash player. Do us a favor since we pay to play, FIX YOUR ****** RNG which is rigged as ****

I should add I run a standard 60 card deck with 26 land cards in it

Once I get going on ranked I get 3-4 games in a row without any land cards in my draws

I get 3 in hand, then for 8 turns straight no land cards drawn and I am forced to play the match with 3 lands

This is clearly rigged, I don't mind losing to my opponent but I do mind losing to rng rigged to MAKE me lose.

Can you please remove the feature that clearly stops me from drawing land cards when I am in a easily winnable position, I can legitimately predict when it is going to happen.

This isn't fun, I run 26 land cards there is ZERO MATHIMATICAL reasoning I shouldn't draw one land card in 8 turns, FOUR MATCHES IN A ROW!!!!!

FIX THIS CLEARLY RIGGED ****

私はMTGアリーナのAIは、
「おっ、こいつ連勝してきたな…土地事故らせたろ！」
「土地事故しすぎもマンネリやし土地だけ引かせまくったろ！」
「こいつのデッキはこの戦法か…よし、ガンメタのこいつ相手にしたろ！」
みたいな畜生だと認識している。

上記のツイートがX(旧Twitter)で流れていました。貴社が提供している「マジック・ザ・ギャザリングアリーナ」では、ユーザーに意図的に不利になる仕組みが導入されているのでしょうか？

もしそうだとしたらなら、ユーザーに対しての冒涜や不義理を実施しているのと同じです。速やかに改善を要求します。

また、シャッフル機能やマッチングなども一時的にこちらに有利になることをして解消した気にさせることは根本的な解決とは言えませんので、そこは念頭に置いてください。

※一時的にこちらに有利になること
例
有利な相手とだけマッチングさせる
相手を意図的に事故らせる

I like how tons of other people are saying how rigged this game is for f2p players vs p2w players and its sadly ****** true how greedy wizards is. I tested it out for myself because i didnt believe it at first. You have WAY less of a chance to pull the lands you need at start vs if you are a buyer in the game the draws are normal. It will give opposite lands from the lands you actually need. I even made a deck with 5 islands and 15 swamps and it would start me out with things like 3 islands and no swamps almost 100% of the time. ******* pathetic company. Your game is going to die once other tcg comes and people realise how sad of a company you are. For example, Flesh and Blood and Lorcana. Piece of **** wizards. No wonder you guys never gain traction and your collectors for your pity attempt of making this game more of a collectors trading card then an actual ****** game because of greed.

Something is wrong with the shuffle algorithm, it's not truly random, I don't know how to explain it other than when I'm playing historic brawl 85 out of 100 games I have a bad mana start doesn't really matter what deck I'm using at best I only get two maybe three mana out of five turns somehow this needs to be adjusted correctly understandable bad hands happen periodically but they shouldn't be so often

I noticed this a few months ago. That extremely low probability draws sequence occur far too frequently to be organic.

What I just realized now is that it is, must be, profit related. That's WoTC only motivation here.

I'm close to the gems required to get mastery without paying a cent. So I build up coin slowly to enter the premier 10,000 coin draft. Win the first game easily, next three in a row I get absolutely absurd land draw rates. at or on pace for 11 then 12 then 12 lands of 16 after drawing only 20/40 cards.

Best guess is they dial up the bad draw when leaving it to chance could jeopardize profit according to their algorithms. And/or do it according to your play patterns to try to get you to keep playing.

Playing in standard, every match is either all lands or no lands. When I have 23 lands in my 60 card deck, have 7 on table, and then 5 more lands in a row, there are some real statistical issues. Add in that the next match, I'll draw no lands outside of my starting hand for another 6-8 turns....

There's plenty of talk and "proof" seen out there about the shuffler giving some people advantages, as silly as it sounds, it's more believable the more I play and see how the game is doing something.

I'm so tired of always playing decks that have already made it to mythic at least every other opponent. makes it unfun to play. also your draw algorithm is suspect.

I just played three different angel decks in a row. Your algorithm set me up against three decks in a row that had "destroy all creatures." That's your idea of how to defeat angel decks? That's unacceptable. Give us RANDOM opponents!

デッキの構成割合を完全無視で、
マッチを楽しめましたか

と聞いてくるが、

わかっていて
異様な工作をしていることが不快。

かなりパターンがきまっている（少しの誤差で、必要なカードを寄せている）様子。

22/68　が土地のデッキだが、
また、3回目まで（７，６，５枚の手札で）土地０が発生した。
そんなにそれが起こる可能性が高いか。

とりあえず10回ランク戦3セットマッチをした結果、

土地が22/67のデッキだが、

初手が土地1枚以下だったケースが

8/24

1/3の確率で土地が1枚以下だった。

結構な違和感を感じている。

途中6/7が土地
最初の３回の手札で土地0
だったときもあるが。