Algorithm Improvement
I'm sure you're getting a lot of complaints about how one-sided your algorithm is not being impartial and often times screwing over players with land draws that should not be happening in a purely random sample - so my complaint can be added to that pile.
But, an idea for changing the algorithm to improve randomization would be having the program assign a number to each card remaining in a deck and pile shuffling the cards into X amount of piles (let's say 6). It can repeat this process Y amount of times then take the middle of the pile and put those cards on top. A better template would be from the card shuffler for poker sets from stores.
-
Rynkar#98080 commented
you know, i bet the only people who actually have fun games are those rancid apologists on reddit that swear up and down that 'no no, 100 times going second in a row is just statistics, you just don't count when you go first' and all those lazy, half assed excuses to justify why this game isn't smegma licking dogshit. They must have whaled hard enough to get the real mastery pass, or just whored themselves out to the ***** devs still slurping hasbro **** without pause.
-
Rynkar#98080 commented
it's not a bad algorithm, it's just rigged. File a complaint after 30 games of going second against the most broken, unfair, unlikely, impossible draws and hands your opponents have and win with in less than 3 turns, a bot will instantly reply with NO IT'S NOT RIGGED, WORKING AS INTENDED as the dev's slurp hasbro **** and gulp down *** by the bucket. No management of the game, no balancing, no addressing the endless amount of very vocal complaining from the majorities, nothing. Useless, *******. No one is doing their job. No one.
-
Seraph#92197 commented
This mana flooding is ridiculous. It’s been posted here for months now and never gets addressed. Here’s an example and I’ll be posting EVERY SINGLE INSTANCE OF THIS UNTIL IT IS FIXED.
-
Listless#95565 commented
**** its so Rigged I can tell by my opening hand what deck my opponent is playing and if i will get manna flooded or screwed...
-
Sagat#53343 commented
fix the shuffler and don´t delete this topic
-
Hendo1983#79457 commented
I noticed I was rarely ever on the play in the vast majority of ranked historic best of one games I played. One day I played 10 games in a row and was on the draw every single time. How is this possible if it’s supposed to be a 50/50 chance to be on the play or on the draw? I’m starting to think people are hacking the game to give themselves an advantage with the algorithm. Has anybody else experienced something similar?
-
doormat#86464 commented
how do you guys explain when half my deck is mana and im going against a guy with a 100 card deck he has better mana draw and curve then me
how do i get ****** on mana 1/3 of the games i play when half my deck is mana
how does this guy counter everything i play with a 100 card deck
stop ******* rigging every game you **** tier compay
the second image is the second game after this one
both times i start with 3 lands and by turn 5 i still have 3 lands
every other game is me getting no lands.
i have 27 lands in a 60 card deck how does this happen to me every other game
fix your ******* shuffler -
Hollywood Ugly#93485 commented
Dude,
I am at Bronze, have lost many game sin a row (Quick Draft) and they are matching me up against nothing but Gold/Platinum nd Mythic. GARBAGE!
-
cutbreak9#84534 commented
Tang ina niyo Hasbro!!! CEO niyo maliit ang tite!
-
1 Damage#82487 commented
Your shuffle system stinks, mana screwed or mana flooded....
1 game I drew 7 lands in a row, costing me the game....
last game I only drew black mana, 8th land draw was green, costing me the game.
It's either the shuffle is bugged or your system hinders game play...
I wonder if you will be honest and say which is true! -
CMCR#09820 commented
Shuffler is worst than ever and this game is quickly beckoming idiotic. It really feels like wizards wants to force a new meta by making it impossible to use older strategies even when they would be completely balanced. Every single feedback I give has been negative. Never happened before.
-
Tmarv#98306 commented
IT IS SO BLATENTLY OBVIOUSLY THAT YOU'VE CONTINUE TO CHEAT AGAINST ME. i HAVE LOGGED EVERYTHING AND TAKEN SCREEN CAPTURES AND WILL POST YOU INTO OBLIVION ON SOCIAL MEDIA. I AM PLAYING THE HIGHEST WINRATE DECK AGAINST INFERIOR DECKS AND THEY ALWAYS DRAW THE RIGHT CARD AND THE LAST 2 TIMES IT SAID "YOU GO FIRST", I WASN'T ABLE TO PLAY FIRST!
-
fishtrees77#61100 commented
I saw a similar complaint mentioning specifically mono red match making only against other red decks. I built a mono blue delver deck and get paired against mono blue decks for days. The same is true of mono red, mono green, mono black. I just built a mono white control list 3 days ago and I have only been matched against one deck that wasn't mono white and it was a white deck with one off color land on turn 7. Match making should be random, NOT an attempted mirror match every time. It's not enjoyable at all. Fix your product. You saw record profits for years because of Arena.
-
Tmarv#98306 commented
EITHER PLAYER IS CHEATING OR YOU CHEAT! i HAVEN'T GONE FIRST IN 15 GAMES!
-
Tmarv#98306 commented
7 LAND DRAWS IN A ROW IS STUPID! IT HAPPENS ALL THE TIME. PLAYERS PLAYING UNFAIR DECKS! FIX THIS ******** NOW!
-
BKB-0527#11468 commented
MTGAのシャッフル,先攻・後攻の確率,対戦相手決定は公平に行われているか?カスタマーサポートに質問しても”アルゴリズムは十分にテストされ、意図通りに機能している”とだけです。この書き方だと,公平性は保っていないことになると考えられます。カスタマーサポートに公平性は保てているか聞いても返答は毎回同じで”アルゴリズムは十分にテストされ、意図通りに機能している”だけ。
Is MTGA's shuffle, first/second strike probability, and opponent decisions fair? If you ask customer support, all you can say is that the algorithm has been well tested and is working as intended. This way of writing would not maintain fairness. When I ask customer support if they are fair, the answer is the same every time: "The algorithm is well tested and works as intended."
-
ChrisCocks#33118 commented
Time to drop the sign from the Renton office roof and break all the windows with soup cans shot from potato guns.**** Wizards for using this awesome game to rip people off.
-
Awhoo Thunder#27323 commented
CARDS YOU GET ARE NOT RANDOM.
I cant play this game because of how HARD-RIGGED it mostly is,
and I really feel bad for players spending money on this scam,
even tho they wqont experience this as often unless they play against someone spending more than them.Differnce while playing against players with pets, avatars and stuff is astronomical in 90% of games,
not in way what cards they have, but what cards I GET and also how they always get exactly right answer for anything.
Sometimes even paying players get screwed over to spend more, but not as obviously like free-to-play players to make sure they wont quit. Its rigged in way to make you spend MORE money, if you are not paying at all then its gonna start getting more and more obvious the longer you play. Sometimes its so obvious its making players uninstall.Its legal so why wouldnt they do it ? They are here to milk you.
AVOID THIS GARBAGE AT ALL COSTS!
-
kazu masu#85226 commented
どのくらい偏っているかというと、
80枚のうち(一つの種類の上限4枚のルール中3枚という意味で)3枚のアーティファクトが
10枚で3枚そろう
くらい。 -
kazu masu#85226 commented
初手土地2枚が多い
が、
今度は80枚のデッキで土地32枚の4割で、
17枚引いた段階で土地11枚その程度偏っている。