25870 results found

1. Game locked! Please refund Draft coins!

   Cast Draugr Thought-Thief but couldn't select either player so game timed out and I lost.. Great would have won otherwise

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   1 comment  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

2. see screenshot.. this is pretty typical for the disgusting lack of attention to detail of the programmers ..lazy programing is all it is

   um, most of the time trample creatures have a red aura that flickers, and at the very least it should be showing up as a symbol.. the fact that the card says ... does not tell me AANYtHING! um theres plenty of room in the upper left to put the numbers and more symbols etc.. putting just some of the symbols is not ok, if you dont want to put all the ability symbols then just DONT USE SYMBOLS at all and that way ill be forced to always read the card instead of relying on the stupid dam symbols.. the most important ability of this creature was TRAMPLE not indestructible.. and honestly the way the artifact is displayed almost 96% behind the creature, i cant even tell at a glance which artifact is even attached to it.. maybe MOVE THE ATTACHED CARD FURTHER OUT SO WE CAN ACTUALLY SEE IT!

   um, most of the time trample creatures have a red aura that flickers, and at the very least it should be showing up as a symbol.. the fact that the card says ... does not tell me AANYtHING! um theres plenty of room in the upper left to put the numbers and more symbols etc.. putting just some of the symbols is not ok, if you dont want to put all the ability symbols then just DONT USE SYMBOLS at all and that way ill be forced to always read the card instead of relying on the stupid dam symbols..… more

   •  

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

3. Ban Tibalt Trickery

   Turn two Ulamog, Ugin, Genesis Ultimatum, etc. Who thought this was a good idea? Love the idea of a red counter with a drawback, but the wording should have been an opponent's spell. Turned a good idea into a sigh worthy trend.

   53 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   8 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

4. this is minor issue but... THE MUSIC NEEDS to STOP changing volume levels!

   the music is fine, its good, its nice, but i have it muted all the time now, why? because you guys decided its ok to play music that has lulls of near silence followed by super loud crescendos of super high volume! i shouldnt have to hire a DJ or be a DJ and constantly keep changing the volume up and down and up and down depending on which part of the music is playing. the music is supposed to be at a steady constant volume. so that way someone can set the music volume at a comfortable level and leave it alone. do i need to elaborate? please make alll the music be at the same level of volume throughout, so that i can once again listen to the nice game music without it being obnoxious.

   the music is fine, its good, its nice, but i have it muted all the time now, why? because you guys decided its ok to play music that has lulls of near silence followed by super loud crescendos of super high volume! i shouldnt have to hire a DJ or be a DJ and constantly keep changing the volume up and down and up and down depending on which part of the music is playing. the music is supposed to be at a steady constant volume. so that way someone can set the music volume at a comfortable level and… more

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

5. make the programmers PLAY MTGO and learn from it , PUT IN AUTOYIELDING for any card! right click to select yielding!

   another idea that should have been implemented since the BETA.. just like MTGO, you need to be able to right click ANY card and have a way to select "ALWAYS AUTO YIELD TO THIS CARDS EFFECTS"! its so obvious! i dont need to click resolve or resolve all a zillion times. i dont need to click autopass and lose because of autopassing something important.. it needs to be on a card by card basis.. for instance a lame harmless card like midnight clock and all its counters.. i cant do a darn thing about the counters and especially if there is more than one of them out there i constantly have to click resolve all, no no no there is a better way, its called.. right click the card, click on ALWAYS AUTO YEILD TO THIS EFFECT! then i never have to click resolve for it ever ever ever ever again, ever! yayyyyyyyy .. maybe then when the game asks me if i had fun i can click on :) instead of :( !

   another idea that should have been implemented since the BETA.. just like MTGO, you need to be able to right click ANY card and have a way to select "ALWAYS AUTO YIELD TO THIS CARDS EFFECTS"! its so obvious! i dont need to click resolve or resolve all a zillion times. i dont need to click autopass and lose because of autopassing something important.. it needs to be on a card by card basis.. for instance a lame harmless card like midnight clock and all its counters.. i cant do a darn thing about the counters and especially if there… more

   4 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   1 comment  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

6. needs to AUTO SORT/ORGANIZE the cards that are IDENTICAL! on your hand and opponents hand

   shameful that this is not already done. its bad enough i have to organize my hand and waste time. the game is so lame it will not and cannot even put IDENTICAL CARDS TOGETHER?!? really?! so not only does it leave your hand a stinking pile of disorganized chaos.. but then if i cast any card that shows my opponents hand, NOW I HAVE TO SEE HIS PIGSTY OF A DISORGANIZED MESS as well! so he might have ten cards in his hand and have 4 of the same card, but it takes me forever to know that since the game is showing me his hand unsorted, and so he has 4 of the same card scattered amongst ten cards, and its so hard to even tell what he has in his hand like that! IF THE GAME WAS SMART IT COULD PUT ALL THE IDENTICAL CARDS TOGETHER LIKE IT SHOULD, then i would see ok he has 4x of that card, and then move on to look at the other cards that he has 1x of each! so obvious! dont make us look at disorganized chaos when we see our opponents hands. just put the identical cards side by side automatically ok! xyzxyxzyy = xxxyyyyzz

   shameful that this is not already done. its bad enough i have to organize my hand and waste time. the game is so lame it will not and cannot even put IDENTICAL CARDS TOGETHER?!? really?! so not only does it leave your hand a stinking pile of disorganized chaos.. but then if i cast any card that shows my opponents hand, NOW I HAVE TO SEE HIS PIGSTY OF A DISORGANIZED MESS as well! so he might have ten cards in his hand and have 4 of the same card, but it takes me forever to know that since the… more

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

7. for the 100th time, list simple numerical stats somewhere in the corner like, HOW MUCH CONVERTED MANA YOU HAVE AVAILABLE, to save time !

   ive asked this so many times before, since we are all forced to play speed magic,instead of just taking our time... it is NOT that easy to count all of your available mana sometimes , especially when you have a lot of lands in play and artifacts etc! the game client already knows if i have 12 mana available for instance, so why do i have to waste precious seconds on my game timer to sit there and count all my mana just by eyeballing my untapped lands and artifacts! plus the fact that i should get this same info about my opponents lands too! sometimes this crazy game stacks like a bunch of lands in one pile and does NOT even put a number of how many are there! so just list the numerical stats so i can INSTANTLY know i have x mana availa le! i need to know how much mana i have quickly so that i can decide what to do! if i have 12 mana i can cast a card for 7 mana and one for 5, but if i have only 11 mana i cant do that, so now ill have to change my whole strategy! its hard enough playing a complicated 5 color deck super quickly ,without having to waste time to verify how much mana i have available... before i can decide to start casting multiple spells!and im sure it would be so easy to just have the game display how much converted mana you have total available somewhere.. plus other numerical stats would be nice too,like opponents available mana for instance,and more, but at least do THAT!

   ive asked this so many times before, since we are all forced to play speed magic,instead of just taking our time... it is NOT that easy to count all of your available mana sometimes , especially when you have a lot of lands in play and artifacts etc! the game client already knows if i have 12 mana available for instance, so why do i have to waste precious seconds on my game timer to sit there and count all my mana just by eyeballing my untapped lands and artifacts! plus the fact that i should get this same info… more

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

8. ANY CARD with x in the cost should ALSO have a button to click that says "MAX" ! so i dont have to waste time counting all my mana!

   ANY CARD with x in the cost should ALSO have a button to click that says "MAX" ! so i dont have to waste time counting all my mana!

   this is so OBVIOUSLY needed.. another thing that should have been added long long ago.. you guys used to have a button for plus 1 minus 1, then you geniuses decided to add a plus 5 minus 5, but you couldnt think of this MAXIMUM button ? for example yet again, heliods intervention, it asks what you want to do, you click gain life, it asks WHO to gain life, OMG really, ok me of course duh, it asks how much life do i want to gain.. what if i have like 17 lands out there, but of course, the game wont tell you that you have 17 lands, you have to use your eyeballs to count them, so what if i count them like 3 times and waste tons of time, and still manage to count wrong, so i count 18 lands, so i type in x=16 by clicking plus 5plus5 plus 5 plus 1 ok 16 .. but OOPS oh now i counted wrong i only have 17 lands so x can only be 15 since it costs 2 mana to cast it, so now the spell just cancels itself angrily and i have to start all over again.. oh no wait my timers are gone my turns over and oh no i just lost the game!! but what if there was a smarter way, like having a "MAX" button next to the "+5" button that i could click to tell the game to just use all the maximum available mana for x!?! wouldnt that be just ingenious? ?how convenient.. would that be.. maybe then i could stop running out of time in the middle of casting a card and thus losing over that..

   ANY CARD with x in the cost should ALSO have a button to click that says "MAX" ! so i dont have to waste time counting all my mana!

   this is so OBVIOUSLY needed.. another thing that should have been added long long ago.. you guys used to have a button for plus 1 minus 1, then you geniuses decided to add a plus 5 minus 5, but you couldnt think of this MAXIMUM button ? for example yet again, heliods intervention, it asks what you want to do, you click gain life, it asks WHO to gain life, OMG… more

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

9. give more TIME to play certain complex cards!

   give more TIME to play certain complex cards! like heliods intervention,which asks lame obvious questions like, "which player to gain life?"..duh.. or makes you select targets to destroy because it actually thinks you are probably going to want to destroy your own permanents.

   all the cards are NOT created equal. right now you programmers give people as much extra time to play a basic creature which resolves instantly as you do to play a complicated card that asks you a series of questions.. if you dont answer all the questions in time, the turn ends and the spell goes UNCASTed , and you lose the game! all because of some pissy little strict timer that doesnt understand fairness or care about the fact that some cards take much longer to cast than others! heliods intervention for instance , what if my opponent has like 15 permanents to destroy??????? it can and does happen like that sometimes. i gotta literally click on 15 permanents which takes TIME! this card should automatically grant an extra 30-45 seconds in time the second it gets cast.. there are other cards that take just as long or longer tocast , im not going to name them all..but if you want to stay strict with time, then you as the programmers will have to go thru each and every card and figure out which cards are complex and deserve to be given more time to cast...extraon the game timer when they are cast is needed! ps. duh(obviously)! this should have been done long long ago....

   give more TIME to play certain complex cards! like heliods intervention,which asks lame obvious questions like, "which player to gain life?"..duh.. or makes you select targets to destroy because it actually thinks you are probably going to want to destroy your own permanents.

   all the cards are NOT created equal. right now you programmers give people as much extra time to play a basic creature which resolves instantly as you do to play a complicated card that asks you a series of questions.. if you dont answer all the questions in time, the turn ends and the spell goes UNCASTed… more

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

10. Tibalt's Trickery is Garbage Fire

    Stupid card. If I want to play a game decided by a coin flip, I can do it without giving you my money.

    Fix your garbage fire!

    9 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

11. Suggestion: Spectator mode and multiple packs buy

    Dear sirs, I've 2 recommendations for the quality of the experience in MTG Arena:
    -Spectator mode: add the possibility to watch friends match live, the spectator can only see spectating friend's cards but not the opponent's cards. It's frustrating streaming matches on discord or web view to spectate a friend's match.
    -Multiple packs buy: add the possibility to buy multiple packs in the store without clicking hundred of times on the coin button to buy multiple packs.

    20 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    2 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

12. Ugin not removing a card when using second ability.

    Using Macbook Pro

    Playing unranked to test a deck, Ugin's ability was used in 2 games - Both times checking the CMC of the cards on the field before using the -X ability - Paying exactly the amount - Both times on 2 seperate games, other cards were exiled and left the 1 card on the field which ended the game in the opponents favour.

    Sorry I didn't have screenshots or video footage to show, but it's a bit of a weird one this!

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

13. Declaration in Stone is needed in Historic

    Do you guys plan on adding "Declaration in Stone" to historic?

    In my opinion it is weird that we don't have it as an option considering its importance in Pioneer.
    Do you guys plan on introducing it soon? Thanks!

    3 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

14. [mobile] Please give a checkbox in settings to require confirmation after selecting targets with taps

    If all you have to do to target is drag a card (for example Lightning Bolt) onto another card, that's simple enough.

    However, if you need to select multiple targets with single taps (for example a fight spell), it is very easy to miss your mark - and there's no way of getting a do-over. Once you've tapped the final target, you're locked in.

    Iirc, on PC, you get to submit your choices, but when I cast my Blizzard Brawl in my first game on mobile, the spell resolved immediately after me tapping the second target with my finger.

    If that was only an isolated incident with my Blizzard Brawl, please let me know, so I can submit a bug report!

    If all you have to do to target is drag a card (for example Lightning Bolt) onto another card, that's simple enough.

    However, if you need to select multiple targets with single taps (for example a fight spell), it is very easy to miss your mark - and there's no way of getting a do-over. Once you've tapped the final target, you're locked in.

    Iirc, on PC, you get to submit your choices, but when I cast my Blizzard Brawl in my first game on mobile, the spell resolved immediately after me tapping the second target with my finger.

    If… more

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

15. [mobile] Please add an "add to sideboard" button below the submit button for draft!

    Drag & drop isn't working, at least for me, it's probably not working for others, either. And not having the option to already put cards into the board while drafting is an unnecessary downgrade from drafting on PC - especially giving the current deck building screen after the draft (posted a suggestion on that as well).

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

16. [mobile] Please add an option to disable card selection via double tap while drafting!

    It's much too easy to accidentally pick a card you only wanted to reserve / view, if your screen's a little finicky or you're simply being a little clumsy. It happened to me multiple times during my first draft.

    Please add a checkbox in gameplay options to disable double tap card selection.

    2 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

17. [MOBILE] Please give us different viewing options for Limited deck building (or make them more accessible)

    Currently, we have a tiny list of cards on the right of our screen to view our deck. The leftover pool is prominently displayed, has sorting options and is taking up the majority of the screen.

    That might work for some people who don't start building during the draft at all, but even those would probably appreciate being able to really view the deck afterwards, sorted by CMC, color, etc.

    If you aren't one of those people and you've already pre-built the deck during the draft, the current system is simply a pain. I can see a very pretty collection of all the cards I've already cut - and for the most part, I don't care about them nearly as much as about my actual deck. Without seeing that properly, it's a lot harder to make decisions.

    I'm not ruling out the possibility that an option to do this already exists, but if so, please make it more obvious. I couldn't find a button and the most intuitive way - swiping right to left, to change the pool into a list on the left and display the deck in the center - didn't work, either.

    Currently, we have a tiny list of cards on the right of our screen to view our deck. The leftover pool is prominently displayed, has sorting options and is taking up the majority of the screen.

    That might work for some people who don't start building during the draft at all, but even those would probably appreciate being able to really view the deck afterwards, sorted by CMC, color, etc.

    If you aren't one of those people and you've already pre-built the deck during the draft, the current system is simply a pain. I can see a very pretty collection… more

    •  

    3 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

18. [mobile] We need a way to provide IN-APP feedback. The current way is prohibitively clunky and you're losing out!

    I just tested the app for the first time (Magic player since the late 90s, played Arena during beta) and wanted to give some suggestions.

    • the app then redirected me to this website
    • where I had to log in
    • I then typed a collection of suggestions in one post because there was no way in heck I was going to go through this multiple times
    • and to top it off, the "post idea" button didn't work (latest Chrome on Android), so I couldn't submit my post. (edit: this may have been due to the screenshot I was attempting to attach being a PNG file, in which case, please add an easily visible error message instead of just making me tap the "post idea" button until I get sick of it and move to my PC)

    Currently writing this on my laptop, where at least, it's easier to make multiple quick posts.

    Seriously though, please just give us the option to quickly type feedback in the app and hit "send". Otherwise, the barrier to providing feedback is just too high, plus, people will be more likely to wait until they close the client (and then forget about it).

    If you're worried about the flood of duplicate posts, come up with a simple tag system.

    EDIT: I think I'm now on a general Arena feedback site and I'm not sure how to get to a specialized mobile one, so I'm just leaving this here. Supports my point pretty well, though, and having the same option on PC wouldn't hurt anyway...

    I just tested the app for the first time (Magic player since the late 90s, played Arena during beta) and wanted to give some suggestions.

    • the app then redirected me to this website
    • where I had to log in
    • I then typed a collection of suggestions in one post because there was no way in heck I was going to go through this multiple times
    • and to top it off, the "post idea" button didn't work (latest Chrome on Android), so I couldn't submit my post. (edit: this may have been due to the screenshot I was attempting to attach… more
    8 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

19. Couldn't see picks during Draft

    In my draft, I couldn't pick a card because I couldn't see them. I was auto-chosen a card and I had no choice in the matter.

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    •  

    • 

    • 

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    • 

    •  

    •  

    • 

    •  

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    •  

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    • 

    •  

    •  

    • 

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    • 

    • 

    • 

    794 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    98 comments  ·  Events  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

20. overwhelming splendor timestamp issues with equipment and not stopping equip

    My opponent had a creature equipped with Embercleave and Maul of the Skyclaves. I played Overwhelming Splendor on my opponent and all their creatures should lose all their abilities. Both the equipment giving the abilities and them losing those abilities happen in layer 6 and would then activate in timestamp order. This would follow that the creature gains trample, double strike, flying, and first strike and then it loses all abilities. Instead, the card lost it's inherent abilities, but retained the ones from the equipment. This would only happen if the creature was equipped again (or gained abilities somehow through an aura or other means after Overwhelming Splendor resolves) so that timestamps in layer 6 would be lose all abilities and then the equipment gives the creature those keywords. Granted, in either case the creature will still have it's p/t increased in layer 7 by those equipment.

    Edit: This was actually Embercleave's enter the battlefield attach ability, nevermind.
    {
    Second Issue. The opponent could still equip despite Overwhelming Splendor stopping all activated abilities besides mana or loyalty abilities, which means equip is not marked in the engine as an activated ability. I would not be surprised if crew for vehicles also was not marked, so things need checked.
    }

    I am a judge, I double checked in the judge chat irc when I saw this, it works this way. The equip rule for it being an activated ability is 502.33a. Here are the layers rules explanations: https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/layer-system-2009-11-05

    There seem to be a number of issues with Overwhelming Splendor and layers. Timestamps for it really only need tracked for layer 6. Anything in layers 1-5 will always happen from creatures and anything after will never happen on creatures.

    This affects a competitive deck in Nine Lives, I feel for the unity programmers having to deal with Overwhelming Splendor as it's a well known complex effect from the old card "Humility", but this does need fixed soon.

    My opponent had a creature equipped with Embercleave and Maul of the Skyclaves. I played Overwhelming Splendor on my opponent and all their creatures should lose all their abilities. Both the equipment giving the abilities and them losing those abilities happen in layer 6 and would then activate in timestamp order. This would follow that the creature gains trample, double strike, flying, and first strike and then it loses all abilities. Instead, the card lost it's inherent abilities, but retained the ones from the equipment. This would only happen if the creature was equipped again (or gained abilities somehow through… more

    4 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close