428 results found

1. Bug

   Bug: 1. Choose the "Roku Powerful" combination in Midweek Magic: Jump In! 2. Steam (PC) 3. I get half the deck (The Roku half, I suspect, because I get a ton of green producing lands, but not a single green card) the land count is 28 in a 40 card deck. 4. I expect to miss the rewards because I only draw land cards. It has been frustrating and infuriating. 6. Only workaround has been forgetting about it and trying to come in terms with the time lost on this. Thank you.

   •  

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Events  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

2. Bug

   Bug: 1. Choose the "Roku Powerful" combination in Midweek Magic: Jump In! 2. Steam (PC) 3. I get half the deck (The Roku half, I suspect, because I get a ton of green producing lands, but not a single green card) the land count is 28 in a 40 card deck. 4. I expect to miss the rewards because I only draw land cards. It has been frustrating and infuriating. 6. Only workaround has been forgetting about it and trying to come in terms with the time lost on this. Thank you.

   •  

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Events  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

3. Rank up bug

   I was playing in ranked alchemy and was working to unlock silver. I noticed that it seemed my rank was reset from bronze tier 3 to tier 1 then decided to try and rank up. I got to bronze 2 tier but then when I ranked that up it brought me back down to bronze rank 1. I decided to try and rank up once more to see if maybe I missed something and now I’m at silver rank but on teir 4 it seems. I’m playing on mobile. I sadly didn’t really take any photos to attach.

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   1 comment  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

4. How to Train your Dragon!!!

   How to Train your Dragon!!! The cartoon, AND the New Movie!! I like the Final Fantasy set, yes. BUT... should have made a tandem set with the movie... Toothless is a black dragon!! each color... characters too. Tooo easy to make a Magic set for this "theme". Sure feels like a missed opportunity! Just saying... I make no money off these ideas.... Your WELCOME. I would so totally want and play with a "Toothless" Night Fury Dragon Magic card!!! Pay/hire me and I will keep it up....

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   1 comment  ·  Deck Building / Collection  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

5. Brawl/EDH - Matchmaker isnt Working

   Would be most excellent to make a dynamic matchmaker. If a player has found secret sauce and actually stands a chance, let them pair up.

   However opponent here has 5 colours. What am I supposed to do with 1 colour. Green. The fairest of them all. I’m not talking about the odd game I can win against a slow Golos player. Wishing on my opponent to be bad or to give me a handicap isn’t playing Magic.

   Monocounter spells happens to be ok against Golos but opponent can figure out other ways to play the game.

   I've noticed Bill and Marwyn have a similar treatment to 5 mana Vorinclex. These three can get 4 and 5 colour matchups.

   Whereas when you are running Tyvar Kell as commander, that deck can be quite hasty and win from 1 life and a dream (involving hasted mana and playing your entire deck out to get to Hoof or Shaman of the Pack). (Which is to say Tyvar Kell, when built to have hasty mana, this deck has a decent win ratio, ~55% to 45% matchmaking. Though recently, Tyvar Kell is matching into harder decks.) (Bill and Marwyn have atrocious matchups. Vorinclex feels a bit more fair until you get to the 4 and 5 colours.)

   If Brawl and EDH is so important to WotC, maybe make sure the experience feels good for players. Currently MTGA’s Brawl is missing some key aspects (social aspects).

   Would be most excellent to make a dynamic matchmaker. If a player has found secret sauce and actually stands a chance, let them pair up.

   However opponent here has 5 colours. What am I supposed to do with 1 colour. Green. The fairest of them all. I’m not talking about the odd game I can win against a slow Golos player. Wishing on my opponent to be bad or to give me a handicap isn’t playing Magic.

   Monocounter spells happens to be ok against Golos but opponent can figure out other ways to play the game.

   I've noticed Bill and… more

   •  

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

6. Arabella

   When attacking with Arabella, Abandoned Doll, her ability is auto-ordered on the stack to resolve first. This makes players miss the benefits from synergies like Mobilize or Anim Pakal's "Create tokens" because those tokens enter after Arabella's trigger has already resolved.

   Lowering priority might conflict with cards that add power on attack, pushing low-powered creatures above her effect before it resolves, so it seems like her effect should resolve before those, but after effects that add creatures/tokens to the battlefield upon attack.

   Screenshots show the default stack order putting Arabella first, and the optimal order putting her last after all of the mobilize/create 1/1 token triggers.

   When attacking with Arabella, Abandoned Doll, her ability is auto-ordered on the stack to resolve first. This makes players miss the benefits from synergies like Mobilize or Anim Pakal's "Create tokens" because those tokens enter after Arabella's trigger has already resolved.

   Lowering priority might conflict with cards that add power on attack, pushing low-powered creatures above her effect before it resolves, so it seems like her effect should resolve before those, but after effects that add creatures/tokens to the battlefield upon attack.

   Screenshots show the default stack order putting Arabella first, and the optimal order putting her last after all… more

   •  

   •  

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

7. AI Art Winter Avatars

   I understand that A.I. is everywhere and essentially unavoidable. (Heck, I even used it to edit this complaint.) It can be a valuable tool that, when used responsibly, can enhance an artist’s work. However, the winter avatars cross the line from “A.I. assisted” to “A.I. created” for me and the inconsistencies in the artwork make that hard to ignore.

   Issues with Oko:
   -Oko’s belt has metal rivet holes, but the belt’s needle doesn’t pass through a rivet.
   -There are two belt segments with holes, implying two belts, yet only one buckle.
   -The end of the tucked belt can’t be tucked into the buckle as drawn.
   -The belt wraps three times around his left hip but only twice around his right.
   -The belt should end after the rivets, but it continues behind the dagger.
   -Oko’s scarf wrappings don’t follow a coherent structure. Both ends seem to wrap clockwise around his neck.

   Issues with Vivian:
   -Vivian’s belts appear completely flat to the viewer despite her dynamic pose.
   -Her corset’s base leather layer should have a seam that’s missing.
   -The buckles vary in size and shape in ways that look unintentional rather than stylized.
   -The fingers on her right hand are all the same length.

   Individually, any one of the issues above could be dismissed as an artistic choice. Taken together, though, they point to the irresponsible use of generative art. If these avatars are meant to represent handcrafted artwork, the inconsistencies need to be addressed.

   I understand that A.I. is everywhere and essentially unavoidable. (Heck, I even used it to edit this complaint.) It can be a valuable tool that, when used responsibly, can enhance an artist’s work. However, the winter avatars cross the line from “A.I. assisted” to “A.I. created” for me and the inconsistencies in the artwork make that hard to ignore.

   Issues with Oko:
   -Oko’s belt has metal rivet holes, but the belt’s needle doesn’t pass through a rivet.
   -There are two belt segments with holes, implying two belts, yet only one buckle.
   -The end of the tucked belt can’t be tucked… more

   •  

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Store  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

8. How is this Possible?

   How is it possible that I'm playing a brawl deck with 41 land and almost 30 forms of mana ramp. Yet, I continue to miss land drops past turn 4. I'm lucky to see one piece of mana ramp and 3 lands in an opening hand. In fact probably 80%+ of the time I have to mulligan past my free mulligan just to see a 3rd land. I set the deck in my overwhelming favor to be able to ramp excessively and quickly. However, I'm getting beat in land drops by decks that don't have access to ramp spells only mana rocks. I can't cast a 5 drop all well my opponent playing grixas can get to seven lands to cast a Nicol Bolas planeswalker. Make that, make sense.

   How is it possible that I'm playing a brawl deck with 41 land and almost 30 forms of mana ramp. Yet, I continue to miss land drops past turn 4. I'm lucky to see one piece of mana ramp and 3 lands in an opening hand. In fact probably 80%+ of the time I have to mulligan past my free mulligan just to see a 3rd land. I set the deck in my overwhelming favor to be able to ramp excessively and quickly. However, I'm getting beat in land drops by decks that don't have access to ramp spells only… more

   2 votes

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

9. Standard is a mess and only several dozen bans will fix it

   Gamebreaking cards that need to be banned:

   Vivi Orniter
   Voice of Victory
   Elspeth, Storm Slayer
   Tifa Lockhart
   Kaito, Bane of Nightmares
   Cavern of Souls
   Mistrise Village
   Snakeskin Veil (and all equivalents)
   Overprotect
   Agatha's Soul Cauldron
   Omniscience
   Kona, Rescue Beastie
   Fear of Missing Out
   Anticausal Vestige
   Stormchaser's Talent
   Traveling Chocobo
   Fountainport
   Bloodthirsty Conquerer
   Cosmogrand Zenith
   Stock Up
   Consult the Star Charts
   Ouroboroid
   Bristly Bill, Spine Sower
   Mossborn Hydra
   Sunspine Lynx
   Screaming Nemesis
   and so on.

   Strength of Creatures needs to be brought down to pre-2005 levels in order to match the comparatively weak interation. If you're worried about the typical UW control deck just sitting there doing nothing, just stop printing white board wipes.

   Moreover, the release schedule needs to be slowed down to once every four months to enable more thorough and competitive playtesting (not just testing the set in casual commander), and, to ensure that the game is actually balanced and not yet another mess of one deck becoming 40% of the format or two decks becoming 80% of the format. I.e. what happened prior to rotation resulting in the hearthfire hero and cori steel cutter bans and what is currently happening with the Vivi Cauldron deck.

   In addition, standard needs to be brought back down to two "blocks" rather than three. A smaller cardpool can allow for a much better much more fun game rather than a monotous jank midrange and three turn aggro solitaire decks which is what defines the current standard.

   Gamebreaking cards that need to be banned:

   Vivi Orniter
   Voice of Victory
   Elspeth, Storm Slayer
   Tifa Lockhart
   Kaito, Bane of Nightmares
   Cavern of Souls
   Mistrise Village
   Snakeskin Veil (and all equivalents)
   Overprotect
   Agatha's Soul Cauldron
   Omniscience
   Kona, Rescue Beastie
   Fear of Missing Out
   Anticausal Vestige
   Stormchaser's Talent
   Traveling Chocobo
   Fountainport
   Bloodthirsty Conquerer
   Cosmogrand Zenith
   Stock Up
   Consult the Star Charts
   Ouroboroid
   Bristly Bill, Spine Sower
   Mossborn Hydra
   Sunspine Lynx
   Screaming Nemesis
   and so on.

   Strength of Creatures needs to be brought down to pre-2005 levels in order to match the comparatively weak interation. If you're worried about the typical UW… more

   1 vote

   Vote Vote Vote

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Vote

   We’ll send you updates on this idea

   0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
   How important is this to you?

   Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

   We're glad you're here

   Please sign in to leave feedback

   Signed in as (Sign out)

   Close

   Close

   Submit Rating

10. Implementing Post-Game Analysis

    As a chess player, one of the things I love about apps/online chess is the ability to go through your games afterwards and analyse them for blunders and misplays.

    We see this elsewhere in other games, even fast-paced titles such as Rocket League has the ability to go back through a game and pinpoint moments.

    In a turn-based system like Magic, why don't we have this option here?

    I just missed a play, where I forgot to give deathtouch to my Llanowar Elves to swing for lethal with Fynn on the board. A stupid misplay, but it's made me wonder how many other times I've misplayed and not realised.

    And then I ended up here.

    So, post-game analysis please!

    As a chess player, one of the things I love about apps/online chess is the ability to go through your games afterwards and analyse them for blunders and misplays.

    We see this elsewhere in other games, even fast-paced titles such as Rocket League has the ability to go back through a game and pinpoint moments.

    In a turn-based system like Magic, why don't we have this option here?

    I just missed a play, where I forgot to give deathtouch to my Llanowar Elves to swing for lethal with Fynn on the board. A stupid misplay, but it's made me wonder… more

    2 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

11. Premier draft crashed in the first pack

    I was doing a limited event premier draft for final fantasy set and the draft selection crashed after only 3 picks from the first pack. I was unable to click the avatar at the top to see if the rotation was just slow because a player was taking his time (which is fine).

    However I was unable to click it. After waiting 3 minutes, I left the draft and went to rejoin. I was unable to do so (see screencapture). This event happened about 5-10 minutes before me posting this post (around 11:30am Montreal time).

    I was playing on the steam PC version of arena. Is there a way to get a refund as well for that missed draft? I was able to play other game mode with success at 11:35am without restarting the game, so it really look server side, not client.

    I was doing a limited event premier draft for final fantasy set and the draft selection crashed after only 3 picks from the first pack. I was unable to click the avatar at the top to see if the rotation was just slow because a player was taking his time (which is fine).

    However I was unable to click it. After waiting 3 minutes, I left the draft and went to rejoin. I was unable to do so (see screencapture). This event happened about 5-10 minutes before me posting this post (around 11:30am Montreal time).

    I was playing on the… more

    •  

    2 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Events  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

12. I snagged the Squall Leonhart card sleeve as a Mastery reward, but whenever I try to add it to a deck, I just get the regular sleeve.

    I snagged the Squall Leonhart card sleeve with Mastery orbs today, but whenever I try to add it to a deck, I just get the regular sleeve. It shows as set in the cosmetics menu after selecting and confirming, but always reverts to the default Magic: The Gathering card-back when I save-and-exit to the deck menu or click the back arrow to return to the deckbuilding menu. Other sleeves seem to work fine.

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    •  

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    1 comment  ·  Deck Building / Collection  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

13. havent received mastery pass rewards

    havent received the 2000 gold reward. not sure if i missed any of the other rewards

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Product Suggestion  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

14. fanatical offering

    Perhaps i missed something, but in my last game it appeared that my opponent used Fantatical Offering used my own creature for the sacrifice cost. I didn't see any other card in their graveyard/exile that would have explained what happened to my creature. Perhaps I missed something, just figured it'd be worth taking a look at.

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

15. BRING BACK FF AVATARS

    Bring back the Final fantasy Avatars so I can get Sephiroth how the **** did I miss that???
    Dude...What's going on December 5th BRING EM BACK NOW.

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Events  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

16. Tai wakeen sequencing bug

    Tai wakeen no longer pauses in response to casting a sorcery, which can cause a player to miss the chance to boost a spell unless full control is on.

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

17. people conceding and not allowing for people to reach certain achievements

    people conceding during certain achievements is going to be a pain. for instance milling your op for a win. how many games in arena do you actually have your head explode from a mil deck due to drawing an empty deck instead of conceding. I think there should be an option for players to finish the turn op concedes on, or be able to play until it is their turn. maybe there is a better answer but something should be done or certain tasks will be a headache. also it would be nice for some better rewards for these achievements. even if that means a new set that a harder to achieve, but some actual rewards other than cosmetics would be nice....the simple gold from dailys is a little lame that we dont have more we can do to earn resources in game. but that is a whole nother issue

    people conceding during certain achievements is going to be a pain. for instance milling your op for a win. how many games in arena do you actually have your head explode from a mil deck due to drawing an empty deck instead of conceding. I think there should be an option for players to finish the turn op concedes on, or be able to play until it is their turn. maybe there is a better answer but something should be done or certain tasks will be a headache. also it would be nice for some better rewards for these achievements.… more

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    1 comment  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

18. Enter the battlefield crash

    My client is crashing whenever an ability is triggered by something entering the battlefield in game. This has caused me to time out, miss turns and lose games

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Gameplay  ·  Edit…  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

19. Misprint/code

    I just cast "Sothera, the supervoid" and ended my turn, the enchantment then "sacrificed" .... which would be fine, except my opponent had a creature in play. Is the card wrong or is the code wrong? Or have i missed something stupid? I had other enchantments in play, so i don't think it was a triggered ability i missed
    (i was clearly losing the match, but still wanted to cast)

    And allow more than 100 decks, i play a lot of Brawl and timeless, 100 decks is nowhere near enough with standard etc too!

    •  

    1 vote

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    1 comment  ·  Gameplay  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating

20. 2 picks queue instead of 1 pick

    I joined a normal quick draft and it sent me to the 2 picks queue. I thought I miss clicked but then I played another one, double checking and it happened again! I am sure is a bug.

    13 votes

    Vote Vote Vote

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Vote

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    0 comments  ·  Events  ·  Delete…  ·  Admin →
    How important is this to you?

    Not at all You must login first! Important You must login first! Critical You must login first!

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    Close

    Close

    Submit Rating